Worst Ref Decision You've Ever Seen

[daytripping]

For me the one i'll never forget was barry ferguson chopping down stavrum when he was clean through on goal and about to pull the trigger; imo Mike Mcurry not only got it wrong but blatently cheated that day. If he gave a penalty he would have had to send off the little mink, he waved play on and rangers went on to win.

 

That was one of the days which made me think paying over

[peahead]

rowbottom at ibrox the day gazza assaulted half a team with flying elbows and headbutts !

[fatshaft]

McCoist getting that cup final penalty for backing into Miller, can't remember the ref, but wankery of the highest order.

[RTYD]

Hatley's assault on Micahel Watt that day.

 

 

An experienced keeper would have gone to punch the ball and taken Hatley's jaw with him.

[Jack_Glass]

Out with any AFC game were I've lost count on the amount of decisions that have went against us against Rangers.

 

The worst game I watched was Rangers v Dundee Utd were Levein wanted to take his players off the pitch. Still can't believe how a ref could blatantly throw a game like that because that's not a bad ref, that's a cheating ref.

[Foster14]

I mind a Steven Fletcher goal at Pittodrie which was so ridiculously blatantly offside to everyone but the referee and linesman missed it.

 

Langers had come out to block a shot, Fletcher was beyond him, but there was still a guy on the line. Only one player between the player and the goalline is offside.

 

Seemed like blatant lack of knowledge on rules rather than anything else.

[beer gut]

Don't know who the ref was but we were playing the huns at Ibrox and Hately went down in the box from an Irvine challenge in the 1st minute and the ref gave a penalty. I think it was the 1st tackle of the game as well. Cheating bastards.

[Roberto Larcos]

 

Watch it from 1:20 mins.

 

Not only a clear cut goal, but the Partick player actually catches the ball and holds onto it in acknowledgement that its a goal.

 

However - play on says the referee.

 

Utd

[Noremac]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?gl=GB&v=SqYEpVjpinI

[vanderark14]

For me the one i'll never forget was barry ferguson chopping down stavrum when he was clean through on goal and about to pull the trigger; imo Mike Mcurry not only got it wrong but blatently cheated that day. If he gave a penalty he would have had to send off the little mink, he waved play on and rangers went on to win.

 

That was one of the days which made me think paying over

[NorthernLights24]

I mind a Steven Fletcher goal at Pittodrie which was so ridiculously blatantly offside to everyone but the referee and linesman missed it.

 

Langers had come out to block a shot, Fletcher was beyond him, but there was still a guy on the line. Only one player between the player and the goalline is offside.

 

Seemed like blatant lack of knowledge on rules rather than anything else.

 

I think it was this match - http://www.afcheritage.org/matches/fixtures/mreport.cfm?fixture_id=4945&season=2008-09&squad=Senior

 

I was in the upper RDS and the offside was pretty clear from where I was sitting. From what I remember it wasn't even a marginal offside, it was a few yards offside. We had a man sent off and a penalty that cost us at least a point from that game. I think we appealed the red card on the basis of the offside. That was rejected because as far as the SFA was concerned the red card was correct and the fact a blatant offside was missed just seconds before wasn't relevant.

[Foster14]

Oh aye, he didn't even score it, that is right enough.

 

I think they are fair enough on not rescinding the red card, but the linesman and referee should have been taken to task for missing that offside. As you said, he was yards offside...

[a don in oz]

That English ref in the world cup when he booked the boy 3 times was not bad going too.

 

 

 

 

Actually at the woman's World Cup just recently there was a belter where the ball came off the bar and a defender caught the ball, then dropped it and play kept going...

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Dandyesque]

The first two on this thread have it for me.

 

Rowbotham just edges out McCurry, based on not seeing about 3 clear red card offences in the space of 4 or 5 seconds, despite being 2 yards away and looking directly at the incidents.

 

Cheating of the highest order.

[Miglo don]

First post for me, I waited outside the ground and went mental at the cunt after that game, the fucker smiled at me!

 

Also remember the 92 cup final I think, the yin at parkhead we were 2-1 down after Rico had pulled one back, and child molester gough punched the ball above his head in the box, ref done that thing where they point both arms towards the ball as if to say play on!

[fine-n-dandy]

The majority against us have without doubt been mostly in rangers games but there are quite a few against us in the tic games as well.

 

Zander's handballheader at the piggery that would have secured us (at the very least) a draw & ruined any chance the tic had of keeping up with the huns in the title chase.

 

Oh & of course, this Sunday's game will no doubt have a few, as this could be a game that ends their title hopes already (again)

[Walt Flanagan's Dog]

rowbottom at ibrox the day gazza assaulted half a team with flying elbows and headbutts !

 

The only man booked that day - Stephen Glass for kicking the ball away. I think Rowbotham got demoted for a couple of months after that one.

[DD1903]

Willie Collum deciding to become one.

[OddJob]

Incredible how many BIG decisions have went against us through the years, so how the Tims can bleat about them not getting decisions is laughable. I'm going to nominate Craig Thomson's performance in a Dons v.s Hearts game from 2003, absolutely dreadful refereeing that night and sent off Tosh & Zdrilic, yet let so many Jambo players away with worse tackles. It got so heated that Big Dunc tried to get on the pitch during the match to chin the cunt.

 

Also Dougie McDonald had a howler against Killie at Pittodrie a few years ago, i nfact he was horrific for both teams.

 

But i agree that both the McCurry ones (against us and Utd) and without ta doubt the winner by a country mile is Rowbotham with the minks game.

[tightbreeks]

schumacher v battston.

 

ben thatcher on pedro mendes.

[RabidGiraffe]

For me the one i'll never forget was barry ferguson chopping down stavrum when he was clean through on goal and about to pull the trigger; imo Mike Mcurry not only got it wrong but blatently cheated that day. If he gave a penalty he would have had to send off the little mink, he waved play on and rangers went on to win.

 

That was one of the days which made me think paying over

[OddJob]

Was that the same game where (P)Ricksen got away with assaulting Young "because he needed sorting out" and Amoruso clearly handled the ball in the box but no penalty was given?

Yes, the exact same game.

[sheepiekev]

McCoist getting that cup final penalty for backing into Miller, can't remember the ref, but wankery of the highest order.

 

George Smith.

[madjockmcferson]

McCoist getting that cup final penalty for backing into Miller, can't remember the ref, but wankery of the highest order.

 

 

Remember that one...was fucking terrible decision.

 

Its at about 55 seconds....cunt.

 

[sheepiekev]

Les Mottram

Thistle v Dundee Ushited

Ushited score, ball hits stantion of goal, comes back out

Mottram waves play on....and even despite a Thistle defender catching the ball with both hands as it came out of the goal.

Unbelievable

[Just Jack]

Anyone planning to mention the freekick the ref gave to Italy at Hampden which cost us a place at the Euro 2008 Championship i think it was?

 

The boy got a freekick for taking out Alan Hutton

[The Boofon]

How on earth did the ref give a penalty to Rangers for that. Fucking hell.

 

Watch it again and check Mo Johnston pissing himself laughing at the decision.

 

They were always cheating bastards. There are about 100 decisions for Rangers against Aberdeen you could choose as the winner in this thread.

[paddy]

I was playing for culter boys back in 1999, i scored a cracker of a goal which was chalked off. Apparently, I was offside although a defender was quite clearly 5-6 yards infront of me.

 

The ref was a prick that day.

[The Boofon]

I was playing with culter boys back in 1999,

The ref was a prick that day.

 

It's nae the ref that should worry you it's the boys in D Wing that'll make your life a misery.

[paddy]

Remember that one...was fucking terrible decision.

 

Its at about 55 seconds....cunt.

 

 

Hun ref.

 

Fuck me, snelders was amazing that day!