Jump to content

Best Dons Xi Of Your Generation


Recommended Posts

Just a bit of fun since the season is done. Whats the best combined Dons XI only made out of players you've watched for us? If you only saw Jim Leighton in the late 90s you have to take him on that form and not the 80s. I only really seen the end of Stewart McKimmie so have to take him on that... still probably better than any other right backs we've had since though so he makes it in. Even though he's an arse!!

 

I figure the younger you are the shitter your team will be - which should be amusing. Since I've picked McInnes as manager I'll go for the standard McInnes formation

 

Gaffer: Derek McInnes

 

-------------------------------------Theo Snelders----------------------------------

 

Stewart McKimmie - Russell Anderson - Brian Irvine - Kevin McNaughton

 

----------------------Roberto Bisconti---------Brian Grant-----------------------

 

Craig Hignett---------------------Eoin Jess-----------------------Stephen Glass

 

------------------------------------Duncan Shearer---------------------------------

 

Subs, Peter Kjaer, Scott Severin, Arild Stavrum, Hicham Zerouali, Billy Dodds, Mark Reynolds, Scott Booth

 

 

Looking forward to seeing some oldies teams and some younger hoors!

 

Have we had any decent left backs in the last 20 years by the way?

 

Link to comment

Just a bit of fun since the season is done. Whats the best combined Dons XI only made out of players you've watched for us? If you only saw Jim Leighton in the late 90s you have to take him on that form and not the 80s. I only really seen the end of Stewart McKimmie so have to take him on that... still probably better than any other right backs we've had since though so he makes it in. Even though he's an arse!!

 

I figure the younger you are the shitter your team will be - which should be amusing. Since I've picked McInnes as manager I'll go for the standard McInnes formation

 

Gaffer: Derek McInnes

 

-------------------------------------Theo Snelders----------------------------------

 

Stewart McKimmie - Russell Anderson - Brian Irvine - Kevin McNaughton

 

----------------------Roberto Bisconti---------Brian Grant-----------------------

 

Craig Hignett---------------------Eoin Jess-----------------------Stephen Glass

 

------------------------------------Duncan Shearer---------------------------------

 

Subs, Peter Kjaer, Scott Severin, Arild Stavrum, Hicham Zerouali, Billy Dodds, Mark Reynolds, Scott Booth

 

 

Looking forward to seeing some oldies teams and some younger hoors!

 

Have we had any decent left backs in the last 20 years by the way?

 

 

 

---------------------Leighton-------------------------

 

Wright ---- Miller ------ McLeish------ Robertson

 

 

Jess ----- Strachan -------- Bett -------Weir

 

 

-------------Gilhaus-------- Nicholas-------------------

 

 

Snelders, McKimmie,Rougvie, McMaster, Simpson, McGhee, Archibald.

 

 

 

I don't care what fancy formation you play... that 4-4-2 is beating anyone you put in front of it.

Link to comment

 

 

---------------------Leighton-------------------------

 

Wright ---- Miller ------ McLeish------ Robertson

 

 

Jess ----- Strachan -------- Bett -------Weir

 

 

-------------Gilhaus-------- Nicholas-------------------

 

 

Snelders, McKimmie,Rougvie, McMaster, Simpson, McGhee, Archibald.

 

 

 

I don't care what fancy formation you play... that 4-4-2 is beating anyone you put in front of it.

 

suppose thats quite a good team!

Link to comment

I couldn't name a XI but Drew Jarvie, Joe Harper, Martin Buchan, Willie " The Ref" Miller, Alec fae govan McLeish, Arthur Graham, Brian " A guid Stirling man" Grant and last but not least Hector " The Fash " Brockelbank, a player who should have immeasurably more international honours to his fine name that he has and undoubtedly, deserved, thanks to the GFA.

Link to comment

I couldn't name a XI but Drew Jarvie, Joe Harper, Martin Buchan, Willie " The Ref" Miller, Alec fae govan McLeish, Arthur Graham, Brian " A guid Stirling man" Grant and last but not least Hector " The Fash " Brockelbank, a player who should have immeasurably more international honours to his fine name that he has and undoubtedly, deserved, thanks to the GFA.

 

Lets see yer jambos team jigot

Link to comment

---------------------Leighton-------------------------

kennedy ---- Miller ------ McLeish------ Robertson

 

 

Varga ----- Strachan -------- Bett -------Graham

 

 

-------------Gilhaus----Harper---- Nicholas-------------------

 

Only saw Varga as a young kid but you cant take a player like that out of your team

Douggie Bell was also a player i admired as he had the skill of anyone but never lasted a whole game

Miller best player I have ever seen and will ever see..

weir/scanlan/graham all great on their day on the wing but graham edges it for me

I loved big Doug Rougvie but Robertson was an all round better player

Forward line could have had Archibald as well

 

must be players i have forgot but cant be bothered looking for just now

 

should add when Leighton went to UTD i was devastated but Snelders was a great find and ran him close

bobby clark i never rated so much although i know some who do

Link to comment

Snelders

 

Mckimmie

Miller

Mcleish

Robertson

 

Bett

Jess

Simpson

 

Nicholas

Booth

Gillhaus

 

Subs: Leighton, Anderson, Mason, Shearer, Strachan, Hewitt, Zerouali, Irvine

 

I'd go with a 4-3-2-1, so defence is a doddle to work out, but I'm buggered if I can work out who goes where outfield

To be fair if you had picked Mason in the starting 11 he could play anywhere

Link to comment

---------------------Leighton-------------------------

kennedy ---- Miller ------ McLeish------ Robertson

 

 

Varga ----- Strachan -------- Bett -------Graham

 

 

-------------Gilhaus----Harper---- Nicholas-------------------

 

 

This for me. That team would beat most teams easily, given the fact there are 12 players

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment

Nicky Walker

 

Thomas Solberg

 

Mark Perry

 

Clark Robertson

 

Nigel Pepper

 

David Rowson

 

Dave Bus

 

Derrek Young

 

 

Michael Bird

 

Laurent D'Jaffo

 

Darren Mackie

 

 

So much quality to choose from.

Nicky Walker was never hungry enough, imo. Too much shortbread!

Link to comment

 

 

---------------------Leighton-------------------------

 

Wright ---- Miller ------ McLeish------ Robertson

 

 

Jess ----- Strachan -------- Bett -------Weir

 

 

-------------Gilhaus-------- Nicholas-------------------

 

 

Snelders, McKimmie,Rougvie, McMaster, Simpson, McGhee, Archibald.

 

 

 

I don't care what fancy formation you play... that 4-4-2 is beating anyone you put in front of it.

 

Same as mine I thinnk.

 

But I'd swap Wright for McKimmie.

 

McKimmie's a bit of a prick, but a far superior player.

 

He also never went to the Huns

Link to comment

 

Same as mine I thinnk.

 

But I'd swap Wright for McKimmie.

 

McKimmie's a bit of a prick, but a far superior player.

 

He also never went to the Huns

 

I always thought Wright had a better tackle than McKimmie, though McKimmie was more solid and was rarely pushed off a ball.

 

In truth I'd probably start with Simpson in the middle, just by way of having a ball winner who could boss the midfield, but I'm a flair man myself, and that midfield and attack is all about flair. Four solid defenders and six creative geniuses.

Link to comment

was born 4 days before the European Cup Winners cup final...so don't really remember seeing much of that team play. so will go from the late 80s onwards which I do remember.

 

Leighton

 

McKimmie McLeish Anderson McNaughton

 

Hignett Heikkinen Jess Glass

 

Shearer Gillhaus

Link to comment

Just to be able to have Snelders in goal with Leighton on the bench (only because of kicking ability), two actual real fullbacks in Kennedy and Robertson, side by side with McLeish and Miller, Weir on the wing, Black in the middle and being able to replace him after his inevitable fouling and bringing on Gilhaus makes me wet!

 

Frankly you could play Young in all the other positions cause he's good to have around the place and still win.

 

Jesus, then there's Jess to be slotted in, Strachan, Heikennin, Simpson, Jesus fuck, got to go...

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...