Andy Considine

[Dons Daft]

I wonder if anyone agrees with me that it was a travesty for us to lose Andy. I know he is a bit slow these days but obviously still able to be a virtual ever present for the Perth guys. The way he was cast aside was really horrible given his length of service with the dons. Surely he could have moved to being a back up defender with the longer term plan to be in the coaching side. Goodwin was in his “making his mark” mode when the horrible act took place. I wonder if anyone else remembers his crucial goals over the years particularly against the old firm. As I say a bit slower these days but a helluva lot better than those we have now.

I really believe Dave Cormack should get in touch with him with a view to bringing him home.

[DelMonte]

Get the fuck off this forum.

[For Fecks Sake]

We offered him what, we are led to believe, was a fantastic contract with a route into coaching. He turned it down looking for guaranteed first team football and it was his choice to leave. If you watched him up here a few weeks ago he has managed to get even slower so no way would he be a first pick choice despite our current defence.

[The Gee Man]

How many new threads do we need

[ERNIE]

5 minutes ago, Dons Daft said:

I wonder if anyone agrees with me that it was a travesty for us to lose Andy. I know he is a bit slow these days but obviously still able to be a virtual ever present for the Perth guys. The way he was cast aside was really horrible given his length of service with the dons. Surely he could have moved to being a back up defender with the longer term plan to be in the coaching side. Goodwin was in his “making his mark” mode when the horrible act took place. I wonder if anyone else remembers his crucial goals over the years particularly against the old firm. As I say a bit slower these days but a helluva lot better than those we have now.

I really believe Dave Cormack should get in touch with him with a view to bringing him home.

I agree but probably too late now..Taylor Gallagher Bates gone too.Like mcinnes the  replacements are worse and all these replacements have cost a fortune.

 

[Dons Daft]

24 minutes ago, For Fecks Sake said:

We offered him what, we are led to believe, was a fantastic contract with a route into coaching. He turned it down looking for guaranteed first team football and it was his choice to leave. If you watched him up here a few weeks ago he has managed to get even slower so no way would he be a first pick choice despite our current defence.

The man was negotiating and being advised by his agent just like 99.9% of all pro footballers. Goodwin later admitted he had made yet another “mistake” Andy is dons through and through, not many of them left. 

[jamiesd]

LOLZ

[bonzodaddy73]

10 minutes ago, Dons Daft said:

 Andy is dons through and through 

He's also shite

[strachanmcgheegoal]

Travesty to lose a bid dandy, particularly one adept at Centre Half relative to Stewart and Scales

Poorly advised by a mercenary wanky no doubt central beltified agent.  Again yes.

With the way our luck went this season, likelihood of over extending new cruciate first game back - Probably very high. 

[CCB III]

On 1/31/2023 at 11:25 AM, bonzodaddy73 said:

He's also shite

No, he's not.

Been an integral part of the best defences we've had this century. 
 

 

[minijc]

7 minutes ago, CCB III said:

No, he's not.

Been an integral part of the best defences we've had this century. 
 

 

See, you are doing that thing where you look back at him at his peak and think he's still there, he isn't and he's got one knee ffs.  I've seen enough of him this season to know he is not good enough for us.

[Russell]

9 minutes ago, CCB III said:

No, he's not.

Been an integral part of the best defences we've had this century. 
 

 

So was Shay Logan, bring him home 

[CCB III]

3 minutes ago, minijc said:

See, you are doing that thing where you look back at him at his peak and think he's still there, he isn't and he's got one knee ffs.  I've seen enough of him this season to know he is not good enough for us.

He's better than what we have, which is worth pointing out. 
 

Most goals conceded in the league, by a good margin now. 
 

 

[Ten Caat]

My son is St J season ticket holder.

He's not been impressed with Considine at all.

Knee injury has sadly ruined what was left of his career. Goodwin didn't get a whole lot right with us, but one of the things he did was not giving Consi the 2 years contract he wanted.

[Roberto]

37 minutes ago, steven Nimmo said:

Bring him back as manager now

Ca just say hings. 

[Guest milne_afc]

He looked disabled at the 2-0 game in January 

[minijc]

2 minutes ago, CCB III said:

He's better than what we have, which is worth pointing out. 
 

Most goals conceded in the league, by a good margin now. 
 

 

Very debatable 

[JamieMT]

1 minute ago, CCB III said:

He's better than what we have, which is worth pointing out. 
 

Most goals conceded in the league, by a good margin now. 
 

 

Far better than Stewart or Scales and offered a fraction of what we gave Stewart (no idea what Scales is in). No question in my mind we'd be better for Considine still being here.

[CCB III]

4 minutes ago, minijc said:

Very debatable 

I don't think so. Our defensive record speaks for itself. 

[bonzodaddy73]

7 hours ago, CCB III said:

No, he's not.

Been an integral part of the best defences we've had this century. 
 

 

He once was ok, now he's not very good.

 

[Dynamo]

Hindsight and all that. Would Considine have been better than Stewart and Scales? I don't think anyone can question that he would have been. But then again, I'd be pointing fingers at recruitment as opposed to looking to a 35 year old centre half.

He was offered a deal don't forget that.

[Ten Caat]

1 minute ago, Sooper-hanz said:

Woahhhhhhhhh. How has this happened??

As a youngster he played for a team that St J helped out with kit etc. They all got taken up to McDiarmid and had a day of coaching, lunch etc. They were also my best mate's team so he took him up to matches when he was going. I've no problem with it at all. Most of his schoolmates were arse cheek supporters despite living nowhere near the weeg. At least Perth was within 20 miles of our home and technically were the most local (just) SPL side 

[CCB III]

19 minutes ago, Ten Caat said:

As a youngster he played for a team that St J helped out with kit etc. They all got taken up to McDiarmid and had a day of coaching, lunch etc. They were also my best mate's team so he took him up to matches when he was going. I've no problem with it at all. Most of his schoolmates were arse cheek supporters despite living nowhere near the weeg. At least Perth was within 20 miles of our home and technically were the most local (just) SPL side 

Too right. 
 

Support your local. 

[bruceg1978]

Did you see his performance against up here a few weeks ago?  Made Stewart and Scales look like Baresi and Bergomi

Enough of this nonsense.  He's finished

[Zeus]

Dearie me

[Reed or deed]

15 hours ago, minijc said:

See, you are doing that thing where you look back at him at his peak and think he's still there, he isn't and he's got one knee ffs.  I've seen enough of him this season to know he is not good enough for us.

You say us like we’ve got some kind of standard 😂

[Dal Riata Don]

2 hours ago, Ten Caat said:

As a youngster he played for a team that St J helped out with kit etc. They all got taken up to McDiarmid and had a day of coaching, lunch etc. They were also my best mate's team so he took him up to matches when he was going. I've no problem with it at all. Most of his schoolmates were arse cheek supporters despite living nowhere near the weeg. At least Perth was within 20 miles of our home and technically were the most local (just) SPL side 

Clues are there fella.

Do they look alike?😅

[Ten Caat]

16 minutes ago, Dal Riata Don said:

Clues are there fella.

Do they look alike?😅

Nah. mate is 5ft 5. Son is 6ft 1

If anything, it could have been the other way about. I've seen his wife bollock naked twice. Not by accident. Both times alcohol fuelled. Once skinny dipping at North Berwick beach at about 1am in November. Second time playing strip poker. Both times she had her kit off in jig time. I never pushed things but I think it was there if I wanted it...

[The Gee Man]

16 hours ago, CCB III said:

He's better than what we have, which is worth pointing out. 
 

Most goals conceded in the league, by a good margin now. 
 

 

He was better, the key word is was. Unfortunately not now, miller was far better than we have now but I’m not sure he’d be that player now 

[Dal Riata Don]

6 minutes ago, Ten Caat said:

Nah. mate is 5ft 5. Son is 6ft 1

If anything, it could have been the other way about. I've seen his wife bollock naked twice. Not by accident. Both times alcohol fuelled. Once skinny dipping at North Berwick beach at about 1am in November. Second time playing strip poker. Both times she had her kit off in jig time. I never pushed things but I think it was there if I wanted it...

The plot thickens.

I'm not transphobic so your restraint is admirable!