JumboJET Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 Hi all. In your opinion, who has been our worst player this season? And why? In this Jumby's opinion, the award goes to Shayden Morris. He is absolute garbage, and the 20 minutes Warno gave him against Motherwell at Todders might just be the most pathetic thing I have ever seen. And I've seen thousands of Millertime posts on here. What are your thoughts? Jumby-o Link to comment
RAZOR Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 On terms of ability and standards. Probably Clarkson. Been absolutely diabolical. 1 Link to comment
DeltaRay1903 Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 It would be wrong to single one man out. We win as a team and we lose as a team. All shite. 1 2 Link to comment
Big Hat Logan Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 12 minutes ago, RAZOR said: On terms of ability and standards. Probably Clarkson. Been absolutely diabolical. Absolutely this. Needs to grow up otherwise he will be in the wilderness somewhere before long. I realise it must be really shit coming to Aberdeen from a club like Liverpool but there is no excuse for the performances he has turned in this season. Link to comment
milne_afc Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 Between Roos, Duk, Clarkson and Barron. Jensen and Gartenmann exempt because they’re probably just operating at their own standard. Link to comment
Willo flood Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 Ryan Duncan, and he’s probably only played about 2 games 1 2 Link to comment
Dandyesque Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 Roos because he's played so often and obviously in the same position. One of few. Spilled shots a 10 year old could have held at vital moments Link to comment
Ramandu Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 Too negative jumbo. But I'll still engage. The worst players have been the ones who were so bad they couldn't get a game for us. We are still paying Anthony Stewart and Jayden Richardson. We had Or Dadia and Rhys Williams. Anyone who actually made it into the pitch for us did better than those four. Link to comment
JumboJET Posted April 13 Author Share Posted April 13 4 minutes ago, Ramandu said: Too negative jumbo. But I'll still engage. The worst players have been the ones who were so bad they couldn't get a game for us. We are still paying Anthony Stewart and Jayden Richardson. We had Or Dadia and Rhys Williams. Anyone who actually made it into the pitch for us did better than those four. I would argue that Morris made things worse by being on the pitch. Link to comment
Russell Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 If we're talking bang for your buck then Clarkson. Not helped by Robson's tactics and lack of a competent Ramadani replacement but still disappointed. If we're talking just absolute shite then Gueye seemingly didn't have any redeeming footballing abilities but is scoring out on loan. Morris close runner up, I want to like him but just not up to it. I'd add that Devlin has flattered to deceive, while Jensen and Gartenmann have been bang average with occasional timely tackles but overall liabilities. Then again, while Roos was good today, his distribution and command of the area has been atrocious all season and should be easily replaced next season. On the other hand, Duk has shown glimpes and was another that I was blaming Robson's tactics for their shiteness but has definitely dropped way off from last year. Still, Shinnie, while seemingly played out of position by Robson as the most forward thinking of the midfield, has had way too many not good enough performances where he's seemingly running in treacle after 30 minutes. Then there's his stupid fucking yellow cards. Conversely, Barron has been shite too. So in conclusion, yes. 1 Link to comment
NEM Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 1 minute ago, Russell said: If we're talking bang for your buck then Clarkson. Not helped by Robson's tactics and lack of a competent Ramadani replacement but still disappointed. If we're talking just absolute shite then Gueye seemingly didn't have any redeeming footballing abilities but is scoring out on loan. Morris close runner up, I want to like him but just not up to it. I'd add that Devlin has flattered to deceive, while Jensen and Gartenmann have been bang average with occasional timely tackles but overall liabilities. Then again, while Roos was good today, his distribution and command of the area has been atrocious all season and should be easily replaced next season. On the other hand, Duk has shown glimpes and was another that I was blaming Robson's tactics for their shiteness but has definitely dropped way off from last year. Still, Shinnie, while seemingly played out of position by Robson as the most forward thinking of the midfield, has had way too many not good enough performances where he's seemingly running in treacle after 30 minutes. Then there's his stupid fucking yellow cards. Conversely, Barron has been shite too. So in conclusion, yes. Devlin started off well imo, had a spell where he was horrendous (rumours he was playing through injury?) but has been on a game last few weeks. 1 Link to comment
Russell Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 5 minutes ago, NEM said: Devlin started off well imo, had a spell where he was horrendous (rumours he was playing through injury?) but has been on a game last few weeks. Eh, I think he gets an easy time of it some times because he's a rah rah badge thumper type. Not as good as McCrorie but definitely better than Richardson. And Dadia I'm assuming. Link to comment
Big Hat Logan Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 2 minutes ago, Russell said: Eh, I think he gets an easy time of it some times because he's a rah rah badge thumper type. Not as good as McCrorie but definitely better than Richardson. And Dadia I'm assuming. He’s been one of our most consistent players apart from a few weeks where he had a dip in form. If he gets an easier time of it it’s because he’s one of few that can actually come out of this season with some credit. Link to comment
DelMonte Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 10 minutes ago, Big Hat Logan said: He’s been one of our most consistent players apart from a few weeks where he had a dip in form. If he gets an easier time of it it’s because he’s one of few that can actually come out of this season with some credit. Don’t agree. Think he’s miles below the standard required. Shocking again today. Gartenmann worst player for me. Plays every minute and he’s fucking terrible. Link to comment
ABERDEENROWIE1903 Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 Shaddy Morris, Gartenmamm and Jensen 3 players simply very very poor footballers That's are shite recruitment for you Should never have been allowed to come through the doors of Pittodrie Who ever recruited them at are club should be dismissed from thier role and out of the club Link to comment
Millertime Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 43 minutes ago, DelMonte said: Don’t agree. Think he’s miles below the standard required. Shocking again today. Gartenmann worst player for me. Plays every minute and he’s fucking terrible. He set the tone within a minute with a horrendous pass right out of play People don't appreciate how little things like that can affect the rest of the teams mentality It's why I genuinely think Clarkson is worse this season- it's because of the utter dross around him Make no mistake, gartenmann is absolutely atrocious Link to comment
RUL Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 34 minutes ago, Millertime said: He set the tone within a minute with a horrendous pass right out of play People don't appreciate how little things like that can affect the rest of the teams mentality It's why I genuinely think Clarkson is worse this season- it's because of the utter dross around him Make no mistake, gartenmann is absolutely atrocious Thought he was grim today. Also he appears somehow to actually be getting slower. I’d just risk Ruby next week Link to comment
ERNIE Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 Thing is most of our players have played better this season or last than they are currently.Why? Link to comment
Millertime Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 14 minutes ago, ERNIE said: Thing is most of our players have played better this season or last than they are currently.Why? What? Link to comment
YorkDon Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 1 hour ago, DelMonte said: Gartenmann worst player for me. Plays every minute and he’s fucking terrible. He’s a complete Charlatan. Poor decision making, allied with poor positioning, allied with poor tackling, zero strength (comstantly muscled off the ball) and slower than a week in jail, makes Stefan a complete liability. He and Jensen give Gallagher and the ex-Hun centre half we had whose name I can’t remember, a run for their money as worst centre half pairing ever seen at Aberdeen. Link to comment
Schapenneuker Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 The only 2 players who come out of this abortion of a season with any pass marks at all are Miovski and Devlin. I would say that MacKenzie.....despite some high profile errors......is on an upward curve and is improving, but I simply can't make a case for anyone else. Link to comment
DelMonte Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 22 minutes ago, ERNIE said: Thing is most of our players have played better this season or last than they are currently.Why? I think you mean our players have played better in the past. Having no manager and the shit show behind the scenes clearly hasn’t helped. Some of them just aren’t up to it however. Link to comment
RabidGiraffe Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 I think there's a distinction here between who's our worst and who's our most disappointing. Clarkson and Duk have been disappointing compared to last season, although in individual games they've had some good moments. Roos has been both disappointing compared to last season and shit. Some players have just been shit but hardly played so unfair to single them out. In terms of players who have had a reasonable amount of game time and been around 5/10 or less each time I'd go for one of Gartenmann, Jensen, Roos, or Morris. Link to comment
Broken_Glass Posted April 13 Share Posted April 13 Cormack and the board for his dreadful running of AFC. Link to comment
TheRedPrawcess Posted April 14 Share Posted April 14 5 hours ago, Schapenneuker said: The only 2 players who come out of this abortion of a season with any pass marks at all are Miovski and Devlin. I would say that MacKenzie.....despite some high profile errors......is on an upward curve and is improving, but I simply can't make a case for anyone else. McGrath gets pass marks as well surely? Sometimes I get frustrated that he seems to go missing from time to time but I'd say he's been one of the few positives over the course of the season. Agree on MacKenzie. Almost every other defender has been mentioned in this thread before him, which says a lot about our defence considering the routine slatings he usually gets on here. 1 Link to comment
Bamber Posted April 14 Share Posted April 14 Lots of disappointments this season but biggest is one player I thought would kick on but has completely disappeared. - Ryan Duncan Link to comment
Sonoftherock Posted April 14 Share Posted April 14 6 hours ago, RabidGiraffe said: I think there's a distinction here between who's our worst and who's our most disappointing. Clarkson and Duk have been disappointing compared to last season, although in individual games they've had some good moments. Roos has been both disappointing compared to last season and shit. Some players have just been shit but hardly played so unfair to single them out. In terms of players who have had a reasonable amount of game time and been around 5/10 or less each time I'd go for one of Gartenmann, Jensen, Roos, or Morris. Spot on. The distinction is correct. Duk and Clarkson definitely most disappointing. The worst of our consistent starters have been Jensen and Gartenmann. Difficult to distinguish between two similar shades of shite….but before the last few weeks I’d have gone for Gartenmann, however, he’s had a couple of decent games lately. In terms of the levels shown when they’ve played, Morris has been the worst. Seems like a good lad, but he’s miles out of his depth at this level. Link to comment
ERNIE Posted April 14 Share Posted April 14 Warnock highlighted recruitment as being so important at any club and basically said that's where we've been going wrong. 1 Link to comment
Zeus Posted April 14 Share Posted April 14 Rhys Williams and Or Dadia have been the worst players for the 'Deen this season Link to comment
Millertime Posted April 14 Share Posted April 14 8 hours ago, Schapenneuker said: The only 2 players who come out of this abortion of a season with any pass marks at all are Miovski and Devlin. I would say that MacKenzie.....despite some high profile errors......is on an upward curve and is improving, but I simply can't make a case for anyone else. I did think that of devlin at first, but not now He has really low game intelligence Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now