Top 5 afc strikers

[ericblack4boss]

Probably done before but fuck it will do it again

Mcdougall. 

Shearer. 

Black. 

Gillhaus. 

Nicholas. 

Feel free to rip holes in that list. 

[sooth_stander]

18 minutes ago, ericblack4boss said:

Probably done before but fuck it will do it again

Mcdougall. 

Shearer. 

Black. 

Gillhaus. 

Nicholas. 

Feel free to rip holes in that list. 

Nicholas was more hype than substance, in my opinion. Way past his best by the time he rocked up here.

1 Harper

2 McDougall

3 Shearer 

4 Archibald 

5 McGhee

[Fridge]

Leon Mike 

[Yorston Vasey]

Benny Yorston.

[WesthillWanderersFC]

1 hour ago, ericblack4boss said:

Probably done before but fuck it will do it again

Mcdougall. 

Shearer. 

Black. 

Gillhaus. 

Nicholas. 

Feel free to rip holes in that list. 

1. Joey - goals speaks for themselves

2. McGhee - his importance to the best team we’ve ever had was huge

3. Archibald 

4. Gilhaus - brief, but class

5. Black 

 

[Zeus]

1. Shearer

2. Booth

3. Paatelainen

4. Rooney

5.  Vernon

Shearer was different class. 

Almost had Stavrum in front of Vernon but the hatrick at Tannadice beats him.

Grim times on the whole for me.  A whole load of absolute dross strikers for the most 

[Torry Tosser]

1 Harper

2 McDougall

3 Black

4 Archibald

5 Shearer.

[Sheepo]

1.Mcdougall

2.Shearer

3.Gilhaus

4.Black

5.Mcghee

[alscotoz]

Harper

McDougall

McGhee

Archibald

Shearer

Hilhaus was unlucky.

[strachanmcgheegoal]

In terms of talent you’re in amongst Gilhaus, Nicholas, Archibald but for sheer (no pun) sticking-it-in-the-onion-Bag-ness hard to leave Shearer, Harper, Rooney out.  McGhee (with his mouth shut) gets honorary position for being able to do both against all levels of opposition.  Exactly what we don’t have now.

quick test.  Everyone close their eyes.  Imagine Arild bearing in on goal.  Now open them.  In how many of your memories was he onside?

Sakes Arild.

 

[NEM]

Benny and Harry Yorston 

Paddy Buckley

Matt Armstrong 

gentleman George Hamilton

 

[Tommy]

Harper 

Shearer

MacDougall

McGhee

Forrest.

[Dynamo]

2 hours ago, Zeus said:

1. Shearer

2. Booth

3. Paatelainen

4. Rooney

5.  Vernon

Shearer was different class. 

Almost had Stavrum in front of Vernon but the hatrick at Tannadice beats him.

Grim times on the whole for me.  A whole load of absolute dross strikers for the most 

Would have Billy Dodds on there. 

[Zeus]

13 minutes ago, Dynamo said:

Would have Billy Dodds on there. 

Aye Dodds and Windass were possibles. 

 

Left them out for their Hun tendencies 

[Zeus]

Aye, was spouting off regularly about them regularly when his loon was there though.  Gads. A no no for me 

 

My old man was staying at the same hotel as him in tenerife a few year back and did say he was a good lad tbf

[WesthillWanderersFC]

43 minutes ago, Dynamo said:

Would have Billy Dodds on there. 

Jeez... he shouldn’t be in the top 10

[Simply Red]

Deano never played for the huns. Just his loon. Twitter spat with huns after his son left, so he hates them and vice versa. Good lad.

Charlie Nic

Hans

Shearer (him and mixu where potent)

Windass

Rooney 

(arild offside did my fucking nut in - for a guy who wrote a book, he was a thick fucker on the pitch)

 

 

 

 

[The Cockney Don]

'Charrrrlie Nicholas is a Wanker is a Wanker'

'Charrrrlie Nicholas is a Wanker is a Wanker'

 

Still is.

[sooth_stander]

Charlie Nic probably deserves a thread all on its own, to discuss how good he really was at AFC, or otherwise. 

First 6 months, waaay overweight, totally unfit, and playing under a manager who clearly had no say in the transfer or any interest in playing an attacking style of football that might have brought more out of the ex Arsenal man.

Smithy and Scott arrived and put him on a strict fitness regime that eventually got him playing to somewhere close to his Celtic days but I just think the high life in London dulled his appetite, ambition and goalscoring prowess. 

Probably would play the no. 10 role nowadays.

No question of his ability but top 5 AFC striker? Nah 

[Fridge]

Has there ever been a reason why he never used to warm up?

Never sure in those days if he was playing or not.

[Zeus]

Mike Newell 

[Dynamo]

2 hours ago, WesthillWanderersFC said:

Jeez... he shouldn’t be in the top 10

Fair enough... But for a generation not around in the 80s he may be, if Vernon made it... 

[sooth_stander]

56 minutes ago, Fridge said:

Has there ever been a reason why he never used to warm up?

Never sure in those days if he was playing or not.

Was that only under Portaloo, or also the following 2 seasons under Smithy? Can’t remember 

[CalgaryDon]

From my time of watching Aberdeen.

Rooney

Cosgrove

McGinn (first season when played as a striker)

Stavrum

Lee Miller

 

Honorary mention to Scott Vernon, Robbie Winters AND of course Alex Di Rocco.

 

[WesthillWanderersFC]

22 minutes ago, Dynamo said:

Fair enough... But for a generation not around in the 80s he may be, if Vernon made it... 

Aye, the younger ones on here have some slim pickings if the likes of Dodds & Vernon are anywhere near a top 5.

 

[Dom Sullivan]

9 minutes ago, WesthillWanderersFC said:

Aye, the younger ones on here have some slim pickings if the likes of Dodds & Vernon are anywhere near a top 5.

 

[Fridge]

55 minutes ago, sooth_stander said:

Was that only under Portaloo, or also the following 2 seasons under Smithy? Can’t remember 

He just never used to come out and warm up. Fuck knows why. Always intrigued me.
 

Also used to wear shin guards round the back as that was where he got hacked to fuck.

[Fridge]

15 minutes ago, Millertime said:

Honestly, this is what I mean

Banal, regurgitated tripe

You need to hurriedly reevaluate what needs posted

Ha ha just got this!

[Fridge]

Are you off the meds again min? How the fuck would me staying in AB10 and Hanz (Whom I have never met) staying in Glasgow be the same person.

Anyway seems you don’t remember Shearer, who is your top five?

[WesthillWanderersFC]

2 minutes ago, Millertime said:

Hicham Zerouali

?