Tord31 Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 15 minutes ago, Andy_123 said: Lol. He definitely isn’t pish. No world beater sure, but not pish. Before his injury he’d have walked into every team in the league bar Celtic and the Huns. He was also never helped by being played out of position for years at LB. Out of position? His best spell was under McInnes as a left back. Link to comment
thurso Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 1 hour ago, milne_afc said: Who has said that? Theo Snelders* Brian Irvine Brian Grant Stewart McKimmie Jim Bett Charlie Nicholas Paul Mason Billy Stark Hans Gillhaus Eoin Jess All post G83 legends. Altho he was a brilliant player surely Andy Considine is more worthy of legend status than Hans Gillhaus Link to comment
Guest milne_afc Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 Just now, thurso said: Altho he was a brilliant player surely Andy Considine is more worthy of legend status than Hans Gillhaus Don’t ever quote or reply to me again. Link to comment
TheRedPrawcess Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 Does Considine leaving mean that Hayes is the only remaining player from the LC winning side? Even he left and came back. Robson as well I suppose. Christ even the Chairman has left since we won that. Link to comment
thurso Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 4 minutes ago, milne_afc said: Don’t ever quote or reply to me again. Why Link to comment
Daisy1903 Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 5 minutes ago, milne_afc said: Don’t ever quote or reply to me again. ???? Link to comment
TheRedPrawcess Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 2 hours ago, milne_afc said: Who has said that? Theo Snelders* Brian Irvine Brian Grant Stewart McKimmie Jim Bett Charlie Nicholas Paul Mason Billy Stark Hans Gillhaus Eoin Jess All post G83 legends. What's upsetting for me is that I only remember 1 of these players Link to comment
CCB III Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 45 minutes ago, milne_afc said: Nope, all multi medal winners. Folk would be wrong. Sure they were all magic, heard a great deal about them and seen great clips. That Nicholas goal on the full volley from the keeper springs to mind, used to watch them on old VHS tapes. I never witnessed any of them, though. So, for me, I consider him a legend. Link to comment
thurso Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 51 minutes ago, milne_afc said: Nope, all multi medal winners. Folk would be wrong. Hans Gillhaus only won one medal at Aberdeen ?? Link to comment
Daisy1903 Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 23 minutes ago, Tord31 said: Out of position? His best spell was under McInnes as a left back. Agree. Would also add that Hayes helped him a lot at both ends of the pitch Link to comment
Daisy1903 Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 1 hour ago, NEM said: Duncan Shearer in with a shout as well Booth? Link to comment
Ke1t Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 43 minutes ago, thurso said: Altho he was a brilliant player surely Andy Considine is more worthy of legend status than Hans Gillhaus Link to comment
Poodler Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 3 hours ago, Bamber said: Think with 11 players probably coming in - and if we are keeping suggested trends a good majority u25. A player like considine in training every day would be priceless to help players understand Aberdeen who now is the most senior afc bred player? Looking at the full match day squad I would guess McLennan followed by Mackenzie c’mon how we encouraging the youngsters then have a career with AFC player development ,stability and knowing why Aberdeen has a statue of fergusson outside the ground That’s why I think this is a mistake 1/2 a squad who knows what Conidine and aberdeen means half a new squad who’s view of Aberdeen is either the airport or the rear view mirror If aberdeen FC sign 11 players this summer I’ll donate £50 to my local synagogue (first team/ squad, pedantic arseholes) Link to comment
Ramandu Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 2 hours ago, Andy_123 said: He has definitely had a successful career overall. He’s played his entire career in the top division in his country, played in Europe, played for his country (and helped them qualify for their first tournament in decades), won a proper trophy, 4th record appearance holder for the team he supports, POTY a few times too. There’s a huge number of players who’d bite your hand off to say they had a career like that. I'm being a bit pendantic, but I don't think he did. He never played in the Serbia playoff game, he was on the bench and in the celebrations. He only played in Nations League games either side of it. He's a legend for me. Part of it's about longevity and service to the club. Link to comment
Tord31 Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 5 minutes ago, Poodler said: If aberdeen FC sign 11 players this summer I’ll donate £50 to my local synagogue (first team/ squad, pedantic arseholes) I could easy see it like. It's a long time to Sept 1st. Link to comment
1983 Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 This is what happens when woke dickheads project their sense of entitlement onto a discussion about true club legends. Just because you’ve not witnessed a legend don’t make everyone else lower their standards. I can’t believe someone is suggesting Considine is more of a legend than Gillhaus! Fucking hell. Watching players like Gillhaus, Nicholas, Jess et.al, aka True Legends, was an experience - they gave us experiences to watch - things that we still think or speak about today. Seeing Duncan Shearer’s overhead kick from 18 yards out, or watching Rico lash one in from 20 yards on a dark, wet European night against Torino, or watching Jess collect the ball on the halfway line and thump one past the Gorams and scum in the cup. Fucking experiences, that’s what makes them legends. Not fucking Andy Considine ffs. I’m hopeful you’ll see a true legend play for aberdeen one day, but, until it happens, don’t search for something that doesn’t exist in the pish we’ve endured these past 20 years. 3 Link to comment
Andy_123 Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 18 minutes ago, Ramandu said: I'm being a bit pendantic, but I don't think he did. He never played in the Serbia playoff game, he was on the bench and in the celebrations. He only played in Nations League games either side of it. He's a legend for me. Part of it's about longevity and service to the club. Ah I thought he got on in the Serbia game. If not then my bad. Still a decent career he’s had. Better than most of the other permanent CB’s we’ve had during his time here Link to comment
aberdeen1970 Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 Ach, one club men are pretty rare these days and should be celebrated. Surely we can have the decency to wish a lad all the best who's played for us his entire career. A loyal club servant rather than a legend if that makes folk feel better. It feels like he's getting penalised in folk's minds for not having being good enough to be flogged for big money. I assume its similar for the likes of Lewis Stevenson at Hibs who is another rare example of a guy in his mid 30s who has ever only played for one club. 2 Link to comment
Guest milne_afc Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 8 minutes ago, 1983 said: This is what happens when woke dickheads project their sense of entitlement onto a discussion about true club legends. Just because you’ve not witnessed a legend don’t make everyone else lower their standards. I can’t believe someone is suggesting Considine is more of a legend than Gillhaus! Fucking hell. Watching players like Gillhaus, Nicholas, Jess et.al, aka True Legends, was an experience - they gave us experiences to watch - things that we still think or speak about today. Seeing Duncan Shearer’s overhead kick from 18 yards out, or watching Rico lash one in from 20 yards on a dark, wet European night against Torino, or watching Jess collect the ball on the halfway line and thump one past the Gorams and scum in the cup. Fucking experiences, that’s what makes them legends. Not fucking Andy Considine ffs. I’m hopeful you’ll see a true legend play for aberdeen one day, but, until it happens, don’t search for something that doesn’t exist in the pish we’ve endured these past 20 years. ?? Link to comment
CCB III Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 14 minutes ago, 1983 said: This is what happens when woke dickheads project their sense of entitlement onto a discussion about true club legends. Just because you’ve not witnessed a legend don’t make everyone else lower their standards. I can’t believe someone is suggesting Considine is more of a legend than Gillhaus! Fucking hell. Watching players like Gillhaus, Nicholas, Jess et.al, aka True Legends, was an experience - they gave us experiences to watch - things that we still think or speak about today. Seeing Duncan Shearer’s overhead kick from 18 yards out, or watching Rico lash one in from 20 yards on a dark, wet European night against Torino, or watching Jess collect the ball on the halfway line and thump one past the Gorams and scum in the cup. Fucking experiences, that’s what makes them legends. Not fucking Andy Considine ffs. I’m hopeful you’ll see a true legend play for aberdeen one day, but, until it happens, don’t search for something that doesn’t exist in the pish we’ve endured these past 20 years. Dumb as fuck sentence, that. It's "woke" and "entitled" to argue a guy who's made 541 appearances for a football club is a legend. Words don't mean anything anymore, just whatever Internet people say they mean. You can disagree that he's a legend, I have a different opinion. Framing it as a result of people being more socially conscious is truly the dumbest thing I've read on here. That takes some doing. So, fair play. 6 Link to comment
CCB III Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 Anybody I don't agree with on any subject is woke I am very smart ? 2 Link to comment
thurso Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 18 minutes ago, 1983 said: This is what happens when woke dickheads project their sense of entitlement onto a discussion about true club legends. Just because you’ve not witnessed a legend don’t make everyone else lower their standards. I can’t believe someone is suggesting Considine is more of a legend than Gillhaus! Fucking hell. Watching players like Gillhaus, Nicholas, Jess et.al, aka True Legends, was an experience - they gave us experiences to watch - things that we still think or speak about today. Seeing Duncan Shearer’s overhead kick from 18 yards out, or watching Rico lash one in from 20 yards on a dark, wet European night against Torino, or watching Jess collect the ball on the halfway line and thump one past the Gorams and scum in the cup. Fucking experiences, that’s what makes them legends. Not fucking Andy Considine ffs. I’m hopeful you’ll see a true legend play for aberdeen one day, but, until it happens, don’t search for something that doesn’t exist in the pish we’ve endured these past 20 years. To class a player as a legend is all very subjective to each fan, that’s pretty much been shown by there being a split on if Andy Considine is a legend or not. Link to comment
Tord31 Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 Considine is a club legend. He is up there with Henning Boel etc Link to comment
1983 Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 6 minutes ago, CCB III said: Dumb as fuck sentence, that. It's "woke" and "entitled" to argue a guy who's made 541 appearances for a football club is a legend. Words don't mean anything anymore, just whatever Internet people say they mean. You can disagree that he's a legend, I have a different opinion. Framing it as a result of people being more socially conscious is truly the dumbest thing I've read on here. That takes some doing. So, fair play. Yes. Subconsciously, your little woke mind can’t handle the fact you’ve not seen a legend, hence why you find it hard to define or identify a true legend, but because you’re so entitled, you can’t accept it’s not within your gift to judge. Demonstrated when the best you can come up with is that Andy Considine is a legend because he played 541 times for the club. It’s quite complex, but with hindsight, you’ll reflect in 10 years and admit I’m right. Carry on. 1 1 Link to comment
JamieMT Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 Don't understand the take on Considine from certain folk on here. You don't consider him a legend? Fair enough, it's entirely subjective. But that doesn't mean you need go rubbish a guy who's lived & breathed the club all his days in order to make your point. 7 Link to comment
thurso Posted May 16, 2022 Share Posted May 16, 2022 22 minutes ago, 1983 said: Yes. Subconsciously, your little woke mind can’t handle the fact you’ve not seen a legend, hence why you find it hard to define or identify a true legend, but because you’re so entitled, you can’t accept it’s not within your gift to judge. Demonstrated when the best you can come up with is that Andy Considine is a legend because he played 541 times for the club. It’s quite complex, but with hindsight, you’ll reflect in 10 years and admit I’m right. Carry on. Your just insulting now for no reason. I seen every single player on the list play apart from billy stark I think ( I might of seen billy stark but I don’t remember him) and I’d class Andy Considine as much a legend as them not for the fact he had 541 games but that he was in a winning cup final team. I’d class the 2014 team I watched at parkhead as much legends as I do the team that won the 1989 skol cup final I watched at hampden. If you won a trophy for Aberdeen your a legend in my book. Link to comment
fine-n-dandy Posted May 17, 2022 Share Posted May 17, 2022 5 hours ago, Ke1t said: Simply hanging around for a long time doesn't make you a legend, in my book. You either need to be exceptional - Considine wasn't or Be part of something exceptional - Considine wasn't I'm not saying he wasn't a loyal servant... but Legend? C'mon. Being a first team player for 18+ years (regardless of quality) is actually pretty exceptional. All about perspective because your view would mean that lesser sides are not allowed to have ‘legends’ as players. As I said earlier, JG is a St Mirren legend but he wouldn’t meet your version of what is deemed a legend. Your view would mean that no Aberdeen player can ever be a legend as there is no chance he could ever achieve close to that of those under Fergie Link to comment
fine-n-dandy Posted May 17, 2022 Share Posted May 17, 2022 5 hours ago, Ke1t said: Doubler Link to comment
donswin1983 Posted May 17, 2022 Share Posted May 17, 2022 2 hours ago, 1983 said: This is what happens when woke dickheads project their sense of entitlement onto a discussion about true club legends. Just because you’ve not witnessed a legend don’t make everyone else lower their standards. I can’t believe someone is suggesting Considine is more of a legend than Gillhaus! Fucking hell. Watching players like Gillhaus, Nicholas, Jess et.al, aka True Legends, was an experience - they gave us experiences to watch - things that we still think or speak about today. Seeing Duncan Shearer’s overhead kick from 18 yards out, or watching Rico lash one in from 20 yards on a dark, wet European night against Torino, or watching Jess collect the ball on the halfway line and thump one past the Gorams and scum in the cup. Fucking experiences, that’s what makes them legends. Not fucking Andy Considine ffs. I’m hopeful you’ll see a true legend play for aberdeen one day, but, until it happens, don’t search for something that doesn’t exist in the pish we’ve endured these past 20 years. Agree with all of that. AC has had a successful career, he’s fulfilled (presumably) his boyhood dream of being a a professional footballer, he’s played his entire career to the best of his ability and to the limits of his own capability, at his hometown club. He’s been able to achieve that and sustain it for 19 seasons, which is commendable. However, would he ever make a legends 11, or should he, based on longevity in isolation, I don’t think so. wonderful servant, great dedication to the club, but not one that will be remembered for achievement beyond commitment and longevity. 1 Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now