Scotland Squad

[sebastian1903]

Full squad: Gordon (Sunderland), Marshall (Norwich), McGregor (Rangers); Alexander (Burnley), Barr (Falkirk), Berra (Hearts), Caldwell (Celtic), Davidson (Preston), McManus (Celtic), McNaughton (Cardiff), Naysmith (Sheffield United), Weir (Rangers); Brown (Celtic), Commons (Derby), Fletcher (Manchester United), Hartley (Celtic), Maloney (Celtic), Morrison (West Brom), Robson (Celtic), Thomson (Rangers); Boyd (Rangers), Clarkson (Motherwell), McFadden (Birmingham), Miller (Rangers), O'Connor (Birmingham

 

So Calum Davidson huh............what the fook is that all about?!? Not played for 6 years and is 32 years of age.........complete joke!!!!!

[Adam Wish]

Full squad: Gordon (Sunderland), Marshall (Norwich), McGregor (Rangers); Alexander (Burnley), Barr (Falkirk), Berra (Hearts), Caldwell (Celtic), Davidson (Preston), McManus (Celtic), McNaughton (Cardiff), Naysmith (Sheffield United), Weir (Rangers); Brown (Celtic), Commons (Derby), Fletcher (Manchester United), Hartley (Celtic), Maloney (Celtic), Morrison (West Brom), Robson (Celtic), Thomson (Rangers); Boyd (Rangers), Clarkson (Motherwell), McFadden (Birmingham), Miller (Rangers), O'Connor (Birmingham

 

So Calum Davidson huh............what the fook is that all about?!? Not played for 6 years and is 32 years of age.........complete joke!!!!!

 

"Rangers pair Lee McCulloch and David Weir and Hearts midfielder Michael Stewart also miss out but Derby winger Kris Commons retains his place after making his debut against Northern Ireland. "

 

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/i...als/7583850.stm

 

 

There's no way David Queer should be anywhere near the Scotland squad.

[Tord31]

So looks like the team is

 

Gordon

 

Alexander Weir McManus Naysmith

 

Hartley

 

Brown Fletcher Robson

 

McFadden Miller

 

I think we'll be very very very lucky to get 6 points

[Maguire89]

WTF...

Calum Davidson!? Kris Commons!? David Weir? :o

He should nominate Seve or Zander(when he's fit), but not these daft players !

[At The Border Guy]

WTF...

Calum Davidson!? Kris Commons!? David Weir? :o

He should nominate Seve or Zander(when he's fit), but not these daft players !

 

Thought Commons was pretty good against Northern Ireland. You're right about Davidson and Weir though - Get some folk in who might be still standing by the Finals.

[Maguire89]

Thought Commons was pretty good against Northern Ireland. You're right about Davidson and Weir though - Get some folk in who might be still standing by the Finals.

 

Okay, Commons played some good stuff against NI, but at his Club he's the most ineffective offensive player they have.

[Donmacca]

Is it just me who rates Zander more than Barr? Surely when Zander is fit he's got to be pushing for a place ahead of him.

[Maguire89]

Is it just me who rates Zander more than Barr? Surely when Zander is fit he's got to be pushing for a place ahead of him.

 

As I said in my post above, I also think that Zander has deserved it. He's surely better than Barr.

[sheep_shagger]

Is it just me who rates Zander more than Barr? Surely when Zander is fit he's got to be pushing for a place ahead of him.

 

I agree with you and when Anderson is playing he goes infront of both.

 

Personally i wouldnt have Alexander, Barr, Davidson or Weir anywhere near a Scotland squad due to age and quality issues that i have with them!!

[barassie_afc]

but yogi talks up barr in the media and the media love yogi

[Tord31]

I'd still play Weir for the meantime as the other choice is Caldwell who is prone to absolute shitness.

 

Agree on the others, suprised we still have to play Alexander but so be it. Hopefully one of Barr/Berra/Anderson (unlikely at Burnley)/Diamond/whoever steps up to the plate. As after new year I'd hope for

 

Gordon

 

Hutton XXX McManus Naysmith

 

Hartley

 

Brown Fletcher Ferguson Robson

 

McFadden

[KennyS]

No Hutton's a pretty big blow.

[sheep_shagger]

I'd still play Weir for the meantime as the other choice is Caldwell who is prone to absolute shitness.

 

Agree on the others, suprised we still have to play Alexander but so be it. Hopefully one of Barr/Berra/Anderson (unlikely at Burnley)/Diamond/whoever steps up to the plate. As after new year I'd hope for

 

Gordon

 

Hutton XXX McManus Naysmith

 

Hartley

 

Brown Fletcher Ferguson Robson

 

McFadden

 

Pretty much agree with that, depending on who we are playing etc.. My hatred of Caldwell is well known so thought i'd leave him out of it this time!!

[Donmacca]

I'd still play Weir for the meantime as the other choice is Caldwell who is prone to absolute shitness.

 

Agree on the others, suprised we still have to play Alexander but so be it. Hopefully one of Barr/Berra/Anderson (unlikely at Burnley)/Diamond/whoever steps up to the plate. As after new year I'd hope for

 

Gordon

 

Hutton XXX McManus Naysmith

 

Hartley

 

Brown Fletcher Ferguson Robson

 

McFadden

 

Looks a good team. Think McFadden will play well off Robson

[Brochdoll]

As I said in my post above, I also think that Zander has deserved it. He's surely better than Barr.

Not arguing Barr is better than Diamond but on wed night he was really good when he came on. Looked sharp, aware and unlucky not to score.

[True_Don]

McNaughton might get in at LB, he plays there for Cardiff.

 

I actually think Weir should be in the side, he might not be playing by the time the finals come along, but his experience is important in what is otherwise a very young defence.

 

Hutton is a big miss, as to is Barry Ferguson...Fletcher will be a big player for us. I think Garry O'Connor might also start to find his feet at international level and hopefully start banging them in!

[Dynamo]

I won't criticise Burley until after a few games, but I don't think he's the man for the Scotland job at all!!!!

 

I've said that since day one.

 

 

Neither do I.

[archiemacdougal]

I agree with you and when Anderson is playing he goes infront of both.

 

Personally i wouldnt have Alexander, Barr, Davidson or Weir anywhere near a Scotland squad due to age and quality issues that i have with them!!

 

Give Barr the benefit of the doubt for now, but those 3 others and Gary Naysmith should be long gone from International football.

[Scarface]

Michael Stewart is a good shout for inclusion in the squad, he's had a cracking start to the season with Hearts. Clarkson of Motherwell is merited also IMO and I reckon Kevin Thompson has a lot to offer.

 

My starting XI would be: Gordon, Alexaner, McManus, Weir, Naysmith, Fletcher, Hartley, Brown, Robson, McFadden, Miller