Player And Young Player Of The Year

[Maguire89]

The SPL has announced the nominees for the Player of the Year and Young Player of the Year award. Who do you think deserves to win it? Bebo has also been named for YPotY.

 

The 4 names for PotY:

 

Emilio Izaguirre (Smelltic)

 

Steven Naismith (Huns)

 

Gary Hooper (Smelltic)

 

Alexei Eremenko (Killie)

 

 

And for the Young Player award:

 

Gary Hooper (again) ( Smelltic)

 

David Goodwillie (Scumdee Ushited)

 

David Templeton (Hearts)

 

Chris Maguire (Dons)

 

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport2/hi/football/13078886.stm

[K-9]

Hooper double.

 

Couple of weird nominations there though.

[ScottishJohn]

Eremenko for Player and Hooper for Young player.

 

Wouldn't be surprised to see David Rapist win it.

[Dynamo]

Naismith?? Has he been good? Not noticed.

And Maguire? Struggling for young talent this season!

[DieHardDandy]

F@ck's sake! How difficult is it for you to support the Don in the shortlisted and say Maguire for young player of the year??

 

Maguire get's my vote and the rest of the shortlist can do one!

[zerodon47]

Eremenko. still cana believe killie managed t get eremenko like, deffo the best player in scotland for a while! as much as i hate the rapist id hae t say Goodwillie for young player, altho templeton has looked quality ana.

[OddJob]

Hooper and Goodwillie to win the awards.

[oilcat]

Steven Naismith

 

Isnt there a rule that there has to be a token hun in the voting

[StandFree1982]

How come Derek Young wasn't in the nominations?

[Stoney]

Hooper for both, not much of a contest.

[Scarface]

By a country mile, Eremenko & Templeton.

 

Anything else is Old Firm, West of Scotland, Weegie bias.

[barassie_afc]

By a country mile, Eremenko & Templeton.

 

Anything else is Old Firm, West of Scotland, Weegie bias.

 

Are these note the ones the players vote for ?

[GK55]

For me, Hooper and Goodwillie

[Geoff_Tipps]

For me, Hooper and Goodwillie

 

 

Yeah I agree.

 

Bebo just isn't as good as Goodwillie.

[Maguire89]

Eremenko for myself, he turned Killie from an ugly playing relegation fight team into an ambitious side that shows great football sometimes. Izaguirre has been very impressive as well, yeah, but Eremenko played for a weaker team and shined at least as much as Izaguirre.

Why Naismith has been nominated, I don't know.

 

For Young Player of the Year ... as a Don I'd go for Maguire of course, but trying to be neutral I'll say Goodwillie, despite his ...personality, but he's a better player, like Geoff and GK said before me.