Clark Robertson

[dalet94]

surely clark robertson will be amongst the 1st players to go when a new gaffer comes in he is a liability of the highest order

[fatshaft]

surely clark robertson will be amongst the 1st players to go when a new gaffer comes in he is a liability of the highest order

What a heap of shite. Guy will turn into a quality player.

 

Biggest worry is his father is a steaming pile of Sevconian, I worry therefore young Robertson is of a similar ilk.

[sheepiekev]

surely clark robertson will be amongst the 1st players to go when a new gaffer comes in he is a liability of the highest order

 

I'll agree that he hasn't looked great a lot of the time, but give the boy a chance.

What is he? 18?

Far too early to write off a young player.

There are greater problems than him....Langfield, Hughes, a strike partner for McGinn (if he stays), a replacement for Fraser etc

[Redmist1903]

What a heap of shite. Guy will turn into a quality player.

 

Biggest worry is his father is a steaming pile of Sevconian, I worry therefore young Robertson is of a similar ilk.

 

 

He makes Ian Robertson look like Davie Robertson.

[fatshaft]

He makes Ian Robertson look like Davie Robertson.

eh?

[sheepiekev]

eh?

 

Think what he is trying to say is that one of the worst left backs we've had (Ian) is made to look like one of the better ones we've had (David) by his perception of the current left back (Clark)

 

I say give the boy time, He's only 18 and needs to be given a chance.

[Redmist1903]

eh?

 

 

Have you nae supported Aberdeen for long min?

 

Ian Roberston was a poor left back from yesteryear, David Robertson was a decent left back from yesteryear. I was implying that Clark Robertson wasn't very good.

 

Have you got an answer to yet on what George 'ghost of Chris Anderson' Yule has achieved in his time at the dons to date?

[Redmist1903]

I say give the boy time, He's only 18 and needs to be given a chance.

 

Good call. He's awfa hot and cold though, I used to stick up for him but anytime I've saw him this season I have thought he looked very poor.

[sheepiekev]

Good call. He's awfa hot and cold though, I used to stick up for him but anytime I've saw him this season I have thought he looked very poor.

 

I don't disagree with you.

Last good game saw him play was as a left sided centre half in a back 3 in the cup replay at Fir Park.

But at 18, it's too soon to write him off.....if he's not improved by the end of next season , then maybe we can say he's not up to it, as by then, he'll have played about 60 games maybe?

[sheepiekev]

whats he good at, seriously

 

what are his better attributes, apart from his eyebrows

 

He's 18 - he has the potential to improve.

He may not, we'll see.

 

At least with him there is potential.....bigger issues such as having an unreliable keeper are more pressing.....sadly due to the mismanagement of the current manager, the new manager will be stuck with Langfield.

[RUL]

What a heap of shite. Guy will turn into a quality player.

 

Biggest worry is his father is a steaming pile of Sevconian, I worry therefore young Robertson is of a similar ilk.

I'd love it if he signed for rangers.

[fine-n-dandy]

I'll agree that he hasn't looked great a lot of the time, but give the boy a chance.

What is he? 18?

Far too early to write off a young player.

There are greater problems than him....Langfield, Hughes, a strike partner for McGinn (if he stays), a replacement for Fraser etc

 

 

& Chris Clark

[vanderark14]

typical of a small minority in our support nowadays.

 

why people write of some of our youngsters so early is beyond me. example - Russell Anderson, many a poor performance from him at full back until he became one of the best centre backs in Scotland.

[Stoney]

Nowhere near good enough!!!

 

Compared to shaunessy he is miles behind.

 

Head doesnt seem to be in the game,

[BigAl]

I don't disagree with you.

Last good game saw him play was as a left sided centre half in a back 3 in the cup replay at Fir Park.

But at 18, it's too soon to write him off.....if he's not improved by the end of next season , then maybe we can say he's not up to it, as by then, he'll have played about 60 games maybe?

 

Robertson actually turns twenty in September this year and has already made fifty first team appearances.

[rgudon]

Nowhere near good enough!!!

 

Compared to shaunessy he is miles behind.

 

Head doesnt seem to be in the game,

 

If he put as much effort into his fitba as he does posting shite and pics on twitter about him and his bird he would be roberto carlos.

 

he looks and plays like a total fanny, can see him at cove in three years time.

[Stoney]

If he put as much effort into his fitba as he does posting shite and pics on twitter about him and his bird he would be roberto carlos.

 

he looks and plays like a total fanny, can see him at cove in three years time.

 

Correct.

[tommo1903]

He's quite posh.

 

Also slightly pish and too tall to be a left back.

[tup]

What a pile of shite.

 

He's a very good defender who lacks a bit of composure, I think his long term position will be centre-half, and naturally he looks a little uncomfortable at times when he plays full back.

 

The same thing happened with Anderson when he came through.

 

Clark Robertson will mature into a fine defender, I mean Cove Rangers ffs, get a grip.

[Huntlysheep]

I think he will do ok only time will tell, maybe the new manager will see he's a nae a left back & switch him to CB or may nae rate him.

[tup]

He is 18 ffs, I'd be amazed if anyone came into the side at that age and looked composed in every game. He will only improve as he gets older, and he's doing adequately right now.

 

There is zero perspective applied to the opinions above where he's being written off and I'd disregard these opinions as nonsense designed to provoke a reaction for no other reason than sheer boredom.

[tommo1903]

He's a very good defender who lacks a bit of composure, I think his long term position will be centre-half, and naturally he looks a little uncomfortable at times when he plays full back.

 

Because he is too tall.

 

seriously, can no-one pinpoint any particular attributes?

 

His positional sense is quite good and he's not too bad in the air.

 

His main problem is his distribution which, at his age, can be worked on.

[Stoney]

seriously, can no-one pinpoint any particular attributes?

 

He cant pass......im mean really struggles with simple basic passing.

 

He cant read the game and his tackling is poofy to say the least.

 

If its a fight between him and Shaunessy theres only going to be one winner.

[Huntlysheep]

Our next manager may nae rate him & decide to tak in someone else.

[rgudon]

What a pile of shite.

 

He's a very good defender who lacks a bit of composure, I think his long term position will be centre-half, and naturally he looks a little uncomfortable at times when he plays full back.

 

The same thing happened with Anderson when he came through.

 

Clark Robertson will mature into a fine defender, I mean Cove Rangers ffs, get a grip.

 

he cant tackle, pass, position himself correctly. Not a defender in a million years.

 

Centre back...? he is a total fanny, would get anihilated at centre back.

[Stoney]

Says a lot about him when we would rather play osbourne, jack and magennis ahead of him in that position

[tup]

He cant pass......im mean really struggles with simple basic passing.

 

He cant read the game and his tackling is poofy to say the least.

 

If its a fight between him and Shaunessy theres only going to be one winner.

 

Meanwhile, back in the real world, it's not a fight between him and Shaughnessy at all.

 

As both are different players and will be judged on their own merits.

 

He can indeed read the game, he had a very good game at Tannadice at full back, his passing is not the best for a full back but that's because he's not really a full back.

 

He's put a fair bit of weight on recently, once he matures he will play central defence of that I'm certain, and he will go on to be a fine defender, of that I'm equally certain.

 

I don't think you are being serious with this pish.

[tup]

he cant tackle, pass, position himself correctly. Not a defender in a million years.

 

Cetre back...? he is a total fanny, would get anihilated at centre back.

 

Nonsense.

[tommo1903]

Shaughnessey is admittedly miles better.

[tup]

another baiting trip

 

sad how you have the time to do that

 

The last thing the young lads at Aberdeen need is weegie cretins like yourself who ken fuck all about football giving them unwarranted stick.

 

Just stick to the threads talking about Jimmy Calderwood.