Jump to content

Reserve & Youth Teams Thread


Recommended Posts


4 hours ago, RDS said:

Jack Maciver joined Elgin City on loan from Buckie (previously also with Formartine) for rest of season. Joins up with fellow 2003 Dons player Lyall Booth (previously Huntly and others).

Examples of decent players going all way through our academy from aged 8 or 9, getting pro contracts but not being retained at age 18-19 but finding a level they're good enough for.

I think MacIver will go a good further than Booth. Good luck to them both

Link to comment
9 minutes ago, Granite95 said:

Lack of pathway to first team which drove the move? Understand if you’re not wanting to share much detail

That's what he said and also if you don't make it at forest you can fall down to a higher level...whereas at AFC pathway would be cove etc.

He said couldn't fault AFC at all. It's the overall system that's restrictive. I like Lewis a lot as a player. 

Link to comment
9 minutes ago, Granite95 said:

Lack of pathway to first team which drove the move? Understand if you’re not wanting to share much detail

Remember when Cormack in his Football Manager phase claimed parents were saying they couldn't see a path to the first team for their kids? Meanwhile McKenna, Wright, McLennan, Campbell and Anderson were regularly playing never mind the many other cameos. Wonder what he makes of it now.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
4 minutes ago, RUL said:

That's what he said and also if you don't make it at forest you can fall down to a higher level...whereas at AFC pathway would be cove etc.

He said couldn't fault AFC at all. It's the overall system that's restrictive. I like Lewis a lot as a player. 

Yeah that’s fair enough, guess look at the likes of Terry Taylor making a decent career for himself in England 

Hopefully with this, Akindeli, Pirie will make AFC (and other Scottish clubs) try to see about what can be done to enable more promising players to get a pathway into the first team

Link to comment
7 hours ago, Granite95 said:

Yeah that’s fair enough, guess look at the likes of Terry Taylor making a decent career for himself in England 

Hopefully with this, Akindeli, Pirie will make AFC (and other Scottish clubs) try to see about what can be done to enable more promising players to get a pathway into the first team

Fundamental changes are needed though I think.

Bigger division would give more teams confidence to bring young players in earlier.

And something need done to sort the reserve league situation- personally I’d make it compulsory for all the teams in the top divisions to enter a reserve/u21 league and get those games back to the best level we can.

Link to comment
8 hours ago, RUL said:

That's what he said and also if you don't make it at forest you can fall down to a higher level...whereas at AFC pathway would be cove etc.

He said couldn't fault AFC at all. It's the overall system that's restrictive. I like Lewis a lot as a player. 

Whilst that's true to an extent the lads own cousin failed at Dons but rebuilt at Falkirk and now in Championship with them and system hasn't changed in the few months since Lewis committed to a contract.

All the best to the lad and his Dad but I'm pretty sure the wages on offer as well as different pathway through to EPL2 at U21 level in England played at least a small part

Link to comment
4 minutes ago, RDS said:

Whilst that's true to an extent the lads own cousin failed at Dons but rebuilt at Falkirk and now in Championship with them and system hasn't changed in the few months since Lewis committed to a contract.

All the best to the lad and his Dad but I'm pretty sure the wages on offer as well as different pathway through to EPL2 at U21 level in England played at least a small part

Definitely will be. Especially as pro contracts you sign at Aberdeen are a few hundred. No idea what it is in England but assume more.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment

Until the SPFL make changes to the game and make each team have "X" number of U21's or Academy Graduates in the first team / match day squads, the chances of making it are so restrictive for the young boys.

I get annoyed our young boys leave for peanuts, but i think it's even worse there's no drive from the SFA to encourage our best youngsters to make it up here. I think it's horrifically bad that the old firm regularly field non Scottish XI's.

I remember playing FM all the time growing up, and there was always like 8 players need to be registers from Scotland, and 4 of those needed to be with Aberdeen growing up. But now it seems like we just have a squad of 16/17 or so, made up from anywhere.

Hopefully Emslie is being brought back with the intention to give him minutes.

Link to comment

The big issue seems to be how breach the gap between the development teams and the first team squad.  I understand the suggestion for a reserve or perhaps U21 team with a few overage players, but there seem to be a few barriers to this;

First is cost.  It means retaining enough players in the 18 - 21 age range to maintain a squad, including their salaries, coaching, and other costs, especially when we're trying to compete with the salaries English clubs can pay.  How many players would we need in that group, especially if there's some we'd rather send out on loan for their development? 

Second is number and condition of overage players.  In these days of sports science, players who were on the bench on the Saturday or are returning from injury maintain their condition and return to fitness through training programmes.  Is there a place in these training schedules for a match? Perhaps they'd rather play a bounce game when the players need it/are ready rather than trying to meet a predefined schedule of matches that might set back a player's return or cause an injury.

The clubs would certainly seem unwilling to cover the costs when money is tight in the Scottish game.  I think the SFA need to take some responsibility here if they want a top level international team in the future, but they've got no money either and will be bullied by the ugly sisters into whatever they want to do.

Not saying I've got an answer or I'm against the reserve/U21 league, just their seems to be significant barriers to it.

 

Link to comment
54 minutes ago, RabidGiraffe said:

The big issue seems to be how breach the gap between the development teams and the first team squad.  I understand the suggestion for a reserve or perhaps U21 team with a few overage players, but there seem to be a few barriers to this;

First is cost.  It means retaining enough players in the 18 - 21 age range to maintain a squad, including their salaries, coaching, and other costs, especially when we're trying to compete with the salaries English clubs can pay.  How many players would we need in that group, especially if there's some we'd rather send out on loan for their development? 

Second is number and condition of overage players.  In these days of sports science, players who were on the bench on the Saturday or are returning from injury maintain their condition and return to fitness through training programmes.  Is there a place in these training schedules for a match? Perhaps they'd rather play a bounce game when the players need it/are ready rather than trying to meet a predefined schedule of matches that might set back a player's return or cause an injury.

The clubs would certainly seem unwilling to cover the costs when money is tight in the Scottish game.  I think the SFA need to take some responsibility here if they want a top level international team in the future, but they've got no money either and will be bullied by the ugly sisters into whatever they want to do.

Not saying I've got an answer or I'm against the reserve/U21 league, just their seems to be significant barriers to it.

 

We've probably got a squad worth of boys out on loan.  Supplement that with first team players either out of the picture or coming back from injury. 

Link to comment
1 hour ago, NEM said:

We've probably got a squad worth of boys out on loan.  Supplement that with first team players either out of the picture or coming back from injury. 

We don't have a squad out on loan.

Would have just under a starting XI and two or 3 of them are still u18s so an U21 or Reserve team would involve taking on more players 

Link to comment
1 minute ago, RDS said:

We don't have a squad out on loan.

Would have just under a starting XI and two or 3 of them are still u18s so an U21 or Reserve team would involve taking on more players 

Would it?  We've a first team squad of about 30 players, a good few of whom look rusty as fuck when they eventually get a game.

Nothing stopping us playing some of the under 18's either - folk are screaming for the likes of Boyd to play for the first team.  Surely getting them experience in the reserves against other clubs fringe players is better than jumping straight from playing against kids straight into the first team.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment

Agree with this, it’s to big a jump to expect them to go from kids to mens football with nothing in between, got to have a reserve team to fit all the squad players that cannot make the match day playing alongside the kids giving them experience and pointers. Whole point of senior players. Now it’s disgruntled first teamers that don’t get games and rudderless kids. Doesn’t make much sense. 

Link to comment
16 minutes ago, NEM said:

Would it?  We've a first team squad of about 30 players, a good few of whom look rusty as fuck when they eventually get a game.

Nothing stopping us playing some of the under 18's either - folk are screaming for the likes of Boyd to play for the first team.  Surely getting them experience in the reserves against other clubs fringe players is better than jumping straight from playing against kids straight into the first team.

Haven't counted squad with all the January changes but of the mid 20s to high 20s signed in reality we've Sokler, Besujin and Molloy out long term and Milne and Polvara out too.

We wouldnt need a huge amount extra but with 20 in match day squads for first team and depending which day the Reserves played matches we would need to take in a handful of players or retain some U18s that would be getting released at end of season if it say were to start in August. Also costs of travel, pitch hire if not played at Cormack and other general running costs

Link to comment
4 minutes ago, strachanmcgheegoal said:

Can’t think of many sons who have followed successful fathers.

Haaland but his dad wasn't really successful I guess. Maybe Schmeichel both had solid careers. Maybe more obscure but maldini at Milan, as in Paolo followed his dad cesaere. Paolo son was also at Milan but he was absolutely shite. I also watched kluivert son score a hat trick v Newcastle last week.

I guess there's a lack of motivation if your dad has been successful and made loads of money. 

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...