Unacceptable refereeing against us

[Dave Bus]

20th December: 7 minutes added on against rangers for no good reason

24th December: penalty for st mirren that is clearly not inside the box

23rd January: goal ruled out for offside against Darvel when about 5 yards onside

1st feb: McCrorie sent off against st mirren for getting fouled

4th feb: pollock goal ruled out today against Motherwell for reasons unknown to absolutely anyone, and still not explained.

5 significant decisions against us in the last 6 weeks. 4 of these being game-changing and costing us points/place in the Scottish cup.

What is going on?

The club should be calling this out

[Guest milne_afc]

😂

[Big Hat Logan]

22 minutes ago, Dave Bus said:

20th December: 7 minutes added on against rangers for no good reason

24th December: penalty for st mirren that is clearly not inside the box

23rd January: goal ruled out for offside against Darvel when about 5 yards onside

1st feb: McCrorie sent off against st mirren for getting fouled

4th feb: pollock goal ruled out today against Motherwell for reasons unknown to absolutely anyone, and still not explained.

5 significant decisions against us in the last 6 weeks. 4 of these being game-changing and costing us points/place in the Scottish cup.

What is going on?

The club should be calling this out

St Mirrens third goal on Wednesday. 

[JojoJuan]

The Hibs penalty when Scales was the one fouled by Porteous 

[fine-n-dandy]

Suspending JG for 8 games when it should have been permanent 

[Ten Caat]

So.....are we forwarding this thread to the SFA/ SPFL along with a strongly worded letter of indignation or what?

 

[Parklife]

1 hour ago, Dave Bus said:

 

1st feb: McCrorie sent off against st mirren for getting fouled

Lol. 

Shut up. You look stupid. 

[AyrshireSheep]

You could also add St Mirren getting a free kick for handball against Shinnie on Wednesday that hits him in the face. 

But you are wrong about the penalty on Xmas eve. The foul may have started outside the box but because it continued inside then it's a penalty. 

[Parklife]

You actually missed the pen against Barron at Livi. That was a horrendous call. 

Drop the McCrorie nonsense though. It was a blatant red and continuing to whinge about it makes you look stupid. 

[Zeus]

Kent not being sent off (or booked ffs) at hampden 

[englishred]

As i've said before on the forum somewhere the standard of refereeing is horrific however more needs to be made of it by the club and other clubs outside the old firm.  As soon as there's a "soft" pen against the ugly two there's a media enquiry, sky ask questions ect  We need to make more of it fucking Rangers didn't have Collum for ages after they wrote a letter to the SPFL/SFA.  

[Parklife]

8 minutes ago, Zeus said:

Kent not being sent off (or booked ffs) at hampden 

But that's not a td card (if you listen to all the morons claiming McCrorie shouldn't have been sent off). 

[strachanmcgheegoal]

Don’t agree with OP but since we’re at it Barisic’s tackle on Kennedy in the Semi.

[G man]

16 minutes ago, Parklife said:

But that's not a td card (if you listen to all the morons claiming McCrorie shouldn't have been sent off). 

And Collum is now as bias to Rangers as Walsh and Beaton have always been.

[G man]

1 hour ago, Dave Bus said:

20th December: 7 minutes added on against rangers for no good reason

24th December: penalty for st mirren that is clearly not inside the box

23rd January: goal ruled out for offside against Darvel when about 5 yards onside

1st feb: McCrorie sent off against st mirren for getting fouled

4th feb: pollock goal ruled out today against Motherwell for reasons unknown to absolutely anyone, and still not explained.

5 significant decisions against us in the last 6 weeks. 4 of these being game-changing and costing us points/place in the Scottish cup.

What is going on?

The club should be calling this out

Clancy today made some amazing decisions today from the penalty until the end of the game. The disallowed goal the Clarkson booking , a number of dreadful Motherwell tackles that went unpunished , all very strange.

[Rico1903]

There are a number of incompetent refs. 

[Ke1t]

2 hours ago, Dave Bus said:

 

The club should be calling this out

Should, but won't.

The only cunt to ever really get torn into the authorities was Levein... and prior to that Leishman had a go some years previously. 

Our club, though... nowt. 

There REALLY needs to be an independent body, created by the clubs... a Union if you will... who can present a united front in the face of the pish we're expected to take from institutionalised corruption and incompetence. 

But... nowt. 

 

[fine-n-dandy]

That cunt definitely had a friend stick a bet on todays game 

[CCB III]

3 hours ago, Dave Bus said:

20th December: 7 minutes added on against rangers for no good reason

24th December: penalty for st mirren that is clearly not inside the box

23rd January: goal ruled out for offside against Darvel when about 5 yards onside

1st feb: McCrorie sent off against st mirren for getting fouled

4th feb: pollock goal ruled out today against Motherwell for reasons unknown to absolutely anyone, and still not explained.

5 significant decisions against us in the last 6 weeks. 4 of these being game-changing and costing us points/place in the Scottish cup.

What is going on?

The club should be calling this out

20th December: 7 minutes added on against rangers for no good reason

Rubbish. We were @ it the minute we went 2-1 up. 

24th December: penalty for st mirren that is clearly not inside the box

Nope, the contact continued into the box, hence the penalty. It was marginal, but it wasn't "clear."

23rd January: goal ruled out for offside against Darvel when about 5 yards onside

Yep. Total fucking howler. Shouldn't have needed to count on this instance, though. 

1st feb: McCrorie sent off against st mirren for getting fouled

Nope. With the angles provided, he raised his forearm into an opponents face, what should anger you is the Kent incident in the SF that seemingly wasn't even checked. 

4th feb: pollock goal ruled out today against Motherwell for reasons unknown to absolutely anyone, and still not explained

Horrendous decision, both players are grappling, but when the defending player hits the deck, refs normally give it that way. Also nothing VAR could/should do about that. 

[Russell]

Don't know about anyone else but I don't watch any other scottish games, I'm sure all other fans say the exact same thing. Leave the conspiracy stuff to the huns

[Rico1903]

4 hours ago, Russell said:

Don't know about anyone else but I don't watch any other scottish games, I'm sure all other fans say the exact same thing. Leave the conspiracy stuff to the huns

They do. So it’s either a conspiracy against every team or we simply have a number of incompetent refs. 

[Zeus]

If mccrories is a red then so is thon Motherwell boy yesterday for the foul on Ramadani.

Nae consistency at all. Our refs are boggin'

 

Edit: typo's 

[don corleone]

3 minutes ago, Zeus said:

If mccrories is a red then so si thin Motherwell boy yesterday fir the foul in Ramadani.

Nae consistency at all. Our refs are boggin'

My thoughts exactly, also we concede a penalty when Kennedy shoulders the ball out, yes his arm was out stretched, but it clearly came off his shoulder. Then there was Pollock disallowed goal, in that situation the ref could have just as easily awarded us a penalty for the Motherwell players shirt tug on Pollock. The standard of refereeing up her is laughable and VAR has only highlighted this. Just look at the St Johnstone player red carded at ibrox, colum called over to to check it again because he's obviously got it wrong, refuses to change his decision, red card overturned on appeal. 

[strachanmcgheegoal]

Whilst I know better than to argue such things I’ve some sympathy for Kennedy yesterday.

His arm is out, looks completely unnatural and hence asking for it but it still comes off his shoulder.  The fact his shoulder is there because his arm is out is missing the point.

Had that been at 0-0 I’d have been pissed.

[Saturday's Kid]

Anyone that watched yesterday's game would find it incredible that they had three yellow cards to our four.

[WesthillWanderersFC]

6 hours ago, Russell said:

Don't know about anyone else but I don't watch any other scottish games, I'm sure all other fans say the exact same thing. Leave the conspiracy stuff to the huns

If the clubs accept it without saying anything it’s partly their fault.

They don’t need to embarrass the SFA by hanging folk out to dry publicly.  
They can go as a collective, all cite numerous examples, as for explanations, but do it privately &  say standards are unacceptably bad & needs sorted.

Instead of helping the referees, VAR has only highlighted how fucking shite they are. 

[Redtillimdead]

The Huns never seem to get any bad decisions though. 

[strachanmcgheegoal]

Couple of interesting VAR points from yesterday.  
 

The amount of clear discussion going on with referees without them reviewing stuff.  I get they’ll argue it’s to speed the game up but for that system to work (and For what it’s worth I do) you have to first trust it.  Which unsurprisingly I don’t.

 

Secondly I’ve said all along that allowing typical corner kick and cross ball shit housery to continue whilst taking the handball rule to the nth degree was always going to end in tears.  I assume Pollocks yesterday was chalked off under the “foul play in line up to goal” category.  So it’s only a foul if it’s a goal?  Which gives the CH the green light to foul him the whole game to make sure it isn’t.

[WesthillWanderersFC]

53 minutes ago, Redtillimdead said:

The Huns never seem to get any bad decisions though. 

They should’ve had a penalty at Pittodrie for a McCrorie hand ball.

As should we for a Tavernier hand ball. 

[englishred]

Personally i think all stadiums should have screens fitted by next season so that the crowd are more informed on what is going on,  technology wise we seem so backwards we might as well be in North Korea