Scotlands Useless Referees

[fine-n-dandy]

Obviously Gollum takes the prize for the most useless & probably also the most corrupt since Dallas retired but wonder how long it will be until Andrew Dallas takes the title his father once held so dearly?

 

Dallas will be going some to oust Gollum as Scottish footballs most hated (currently serving) referee though. Hated at least by all except Celtic.

 

Let's see which of our long list of wonderful (elite according to FIFA) referees gets the most mentions on this thread for being fkn useless.

 

Most clubs think Gollum is actually biased against them but I only think this when he officiates our games V Celtic. Rest of the time I fully believe he is just completely useless at his job. But was it him that was ref in the farce against Hamilton also last season? Cannot remember which one that was.

 

http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/hugh-dallas-son-andrew-propelled-4965723

[fine-n-dandy]

First point goes to Gollum for last weeks failure to red card Gordon.

For such a "card happy" ref how the fuck did he only see that as a yellow?

 

Useless or scared to upset the Victims at home?

[BWG]

There's not a single referee in Scotland that can do their job to a satisfactory standard.

 

How many goals did we have chalked off last because of the officials sheer inability to keep pace with the game? The only team that will do well out of their fuckwittery is Celtic, because the referee's in this country are petrified of the backlash from the tims for awarding anything against them. The chart last season with all the penalties awarded said it all.

 

Officiating requires some serious investment in Scotland if it is to improve. Take some money out of the prize and invest it in proper training for the officials. Also perhaps ensure they are in reasonable physical condition instead of having fat bastards slogging down the length of the pitch that are unable to see anything because they are too busy breathing out of their arseholes and pishing sweat.

 

It's fixable, but the SFA don't see a problem and so fuck all will get done.

[Saturday's Kid]

Had the Ross County keeper fouled a Celtic player in an identical incident would the card have been yellow? I am 100% sure it would have been a red. It can never be proven of course.

[Dandie1992]

Wasn't till I went to a lot of La Liga games whilst in Spain did I see how refereeing should be done. No fannying about, referee blows for obvious fouls and only for dubious ones if linesman is in agreement.

 

 

Refereeing in Scotland is utter gash

[Bamber]

I can see both sides of this argument actually - I can see why he would give it and I can see why he wouldn't give it but I see more why it would be given

 

Also I think we need to think here what the spirit of the law is - a lot is made of the fact that it is denying a goal scoring opportunity its not a last man tackle nor is it a professional foul but what was the spirit of this rule? |The spirit of the rule was to stop players playing the player instead of the ball to prevent them scoring

 

Gordon clearly was after making sure he took the player out as far out as possible so that when he did get sent off there was a chance it could be saved it a cynical and premeditated and he knew the likely outcome

 

Compare and contrast to Ward staying in his box and blocking the Kairat player early in the first half

 

Compare and contrast to Samarras Vs Langfield in 2013 - samaras was a lot closer in and going a lot further to the side

 

I can see why it wasn't given I can see why it should be, I think when you look at the spirit of the law and the intent of Gordon it was a red all day long

[fine-n-dandy]

Amazing, not only did Hearts NOT get a penalty today. They actually got one against them.

 

Haven't seen it but (according to County manager anyway) apparently Hearts benefited from only getting a booking for the penalty when it could have been a red card.

[Byrne Baby Byrne]

[fine-n-dandy]

Amazing, not only did Hearts NOT get a penalty today. They actually got one against them.

 

Haven't seen it but (according to County manager anyway) apparently Hearts benefited from only getting a booking for the penalty when it could have been a red card.

 

[Byrne Baby Byrne]

I have to be pretty satisfied with this outcome

[Merkie84]

mcinnes needs to come out with some fergieesque mind games in the press before the celtic game.

 

something along the lines of " big games like this need a referee with character and strength" etc

[Old Wing Stand]

Shortage of referees in Scotland seems to be a lot of budding ones on here !

[fine-n-dandy]

Shortage of referees in Scotland seems to be a lot of budding ones on here !

Sorry. Forgot the first rule of Scottish football.

 

YOU WILL NEVER TALK ABOUT THE REFEREES

 

& the second rule

 

YOU WILL NEVER TALK ABOUT THE REFEREES.

 

 

Idiot

[RAZOR]

Sorry. Forgot the first rule of Scottish football.

 

YOU WILL NEVER TALK ABOUT THE REFEREES

 

& the second rule

 

YOU WILL NEVER TALK ABOUT THE REFEREES.

 

 

Idiot

You just broke rule 1

[dave_min]

You just broke rule 1

 

Think he broke rule too 2.

 

Idiot.

[fine-n-dandy]

You just broke rule 1

I always was a rebel without a cause.

[Old Wing Stand]

Sorry. Forgot the first rule of Scottish football.

 

YOU WILL NEVER TALK ABOUT THE REFEREES

 

& the second rule

 

YOU WILL NEVER TALK ABOUT THE REFEREES.

 

 

Idiot

Referees complained about the world over idiot

[tightbreeks]

Only one way to solve it. Get intelligent ex-pros who couldn't care about scot prem clubs and give them a whistle. They can tell when a player is at, coz they've done it themselves.

[fine-n-dandy]

Referees complained about the world over idiot

& this is the thread for us in Scotland to complain about our Refs (or praise them)

 

You trying to say that our refs are on a par with other Countries?

 

Interesting.

 

Idiot.

[fine-n-dandy]

Haven't had a good look at it but was DG's foul the correct call when he got his goal chopped off?

[Old Wing Stand]

& this is the thread for us in Scotland to complain about our Refs (or praise them)

 

You trying to say that our refs are on a par with other Countries?

 

Interesting.

 

Idiot.

The refs here are no worse or better than than any other countries idiot

[fine-n-dandy]

The refs here are no worse or better than than any other countries idiot

HA. Two words. Willie Collum.

 

 

 

Idiot

[fine-n-dandy]

You just have to look at Celtics card/foul stats in Europe compared to domestic to see that our refs are weak & incompetent

 

 

Idiotic idiot

[Jocky Balboa]

Half of them are Freemasons, with an agenda.

[fine-n-dandy]

Half of them are Freemasons, with an agenda.

The other half are idiots without an agenda

[fine-n-dandy]

Just watching the Partick - Killie highlights.

 

Particks red card (no arguments at all) was a red card for denying a clear goal scoring chance. Even though their would still have been a keeper to beat. Even Partick player had no arguments.

Again highlights just how bad Gollums call was on Craig Gordon in their opening game. Infringement happened in exactly the same area of the park & there would have been nobody in goal to beat. Gollum sees it's a clear foul & calls it right but refuses to give the red card.

 

Any other team in the league & their keeper would have been off.

[RTYD]

They are all cunts

[Robbie Winters]

Haven't had a good look at it but was DG's foul the correct call when he got his goal chopped off?

Watched highlights again and really no complaint from DG so basically admitting guilt but if you look at Collum he more or less has blown and has his hands up pointing for a free kick within micro-seconds so was he going to blow regardless, probably

 

Heard again today that he is away on Chumps League business, how blind are these UEFA folk ?

[fine-n-dandy]

Watched highlights again and really no complaint from DG so basically admitting guilt but if you look at Collum he more or less has blown and has his hands up pointing for a free kick within micro-seconds so was he going to blow regardless, probably

 

Heard again today that he is away on Chumps League business, how blind are these UEFA folk ?

Yeah seeing it again from behind goal angle & it does look like DG gave him a wee cheeky push :giggle:so probably the right call from Gollum.

Fuck how he & his amigos got that gig though.

[Robbie Winters]

Actually very surprised he gave Taylors goal even though the their keeper was bumped over by their centre half. Glaring chance for him to disallow the goal due to an infringement. Think Big Ash would have ripped his heid aff though