Stefan Gartenmann

[RUL]

Be interesting to see next accounts. 
 

don’t think he will sign with Aberdeen under any circumstances full time.

[Tord31]

10 hours ago, Footballs coming Rome said:

Think we sell Miovski this summer for a chunky fee. Use some of that for him and a Miovski mk2. 

Can see Miovski mk2 being the club record signing assuming Duk, Bavidge, Sokler and Gueye (no laughing at the back) dont turn in to Ronaldo in the meantime

[Tord31]

2 hours ago, RUL said:

Be interesting to see next accounts. 
 

don’t think he will sign with Aberdeen under any circumstances full time.

Not convinced by that. Transfer was agreed between all parties before the loan apparently but his club kept delaying and delaying and then hence the last minute loan only.

The picked him up on a free and he'll have 9 months left on his deal when we bother our arse to start negotiating 

[CCB III]

46 minutes ago, Tord31 said:

Can see Miovski mk2 being the club record signing assuming Duk, Bavidge, Sokler and Gueye (no laughing at the back) dont turn in to Ronaldo in the meantime

It's Sokler. 

[Tord31]

45 minutes ago, CCB III said:

It's Sokler. 

Needs to up his game a bit to talk us out of going big on the Miovski replacement.

Assuming its £5m+ for Miovski sale

[CCB III]

8 minutes ago, Tord31 said:

Needs to up his game a bit to talk us out of going big on the Miovski replacement.

Assuming its £5m+ for Miovski sale

Needs to be given meaningful game time in the correct position, which won't happen until Bojan is sold.

[Donscanada]

Curious what transfer fee are we talking for the great dane to make permanent.  Guessing it would be starting at 500k.  

[perthshirered]

20 hours ago, Footballs coming Rome said:

Think we will sell Miovski this summer for a chunky fee. Use some of that for him and a Miovski mk2. 

Sorted. 

[fine-n-dandy]

On 10/14/2023 at 11:16 AM, eeps said:

Lets agree not to use that sentence, very overused these days

Not by us it’s not because it’s only used if you have very good playerS.

So we’ve probably used it on Duk/Miovski & possibly Clarkson last season.

Nobody else I could imagine we’ve used it & especially ‘overused’ it

[Zeus]

On 9/30/2023 at 11:32 PM, Zeus said:

 

But Gartenmann is class. World class.

Been toiling of late 

Could be the manager however 

Struggled badly with that absolute carthorse Kyle Vassell last night 

[Andy_123]

26 minutes ago, Zeus said:

Been toiling of late 

Could be the manager however 

Struggled badly with that absolute carthorse Kyle Vassell last night 

Did he struggle? Vassell did absolutely nothing of note all game

[Byrne Baby Byrne]

Not that good but pats the badge and punches the air well

[Tord31]

he was very good at home to the huns

[WesthillWanderersFC]

7 minutes ago, Byrne Baby Byrne said:

Not that good but pats the badge and punches the air well

His distribution from defence is comical.

Quite why the fuckwit in the dugout tells the defenders to shell it 60 yards when they struggle to pass 15 yards, is beyond me. 

[Studebaker-90]

He’s soft as shite. Really suspect from set pieces. Badly exposed when rubezic isn’t playing. 

[RUL]

22 minutes ago, Andy_123 said:

Did he struggle? Vassell did absolutely nothing of note all game

All he did was foul our defenders all night.

[fine-n-dandy]

1 hour ago, WesthillWanderersFC said:

His distribution from defence is comical.

Quite why the fuckwit in the dugout tells the defenders to shell it 60 yards when they struggle to pass 15 yards, is beyond me. 

Hmmmm maybe the reason is in your own query 🤣 

If they can’t pass 15 yards around box accurately, best to punt it well clear 🤔

 

All makes sense now

[jamiesd]

Every defender is pish.

[bonzodaddy73]

For all his faults Gartenmann is not the problem, we all know who's the problem with this team.

[Howard Marks]

44 minutes ago, bonzodaddy73 said:

For all his faults Gartenmann is not the problem, we all know who's the problem with this team.

The goalkeeper? 

[Dandys1983]

19 minutes ago, Howard Marks said:

The goalkeeper? 

the fucking manager 

[Daisy1903]

I struggle to see anything that Gartenmann does well. No pace, no height, poor passing, weak, doesn't win many headers and not very bright at defending set pieces. Had his chance, time to look for better in January

[Turra red]

On Wednesday night especially I thought the fault wasn't with our defence. They dealt with the majority of attacks well however when your midfield is non existent you will always struggle to thwart every attack. 

I think the defence could be solid and in attack we are well equipped, it's the engine room that's wrong and robson wont change it.

[Johnnyred1]

If you watch the Killie goal, he shat it. He turned his body which allowed enough of a gap for the shot. Not putting body on the line was criminal.

[dave_min]

4 hours ago, jamiesd said:

Every defender is pish.

Gus is decent. Fuck knows why he doesn’t get a game.

[Arthur FN Shelby]

17 minutes ago, dave_min said:

Gus is decent. Fuck knows why he doesn’t get a game.

My thoughts entirely. How Rubicek is ahead of MacDonald baffles me. Probably baffles MacDonald as well.

[Daisy1903]

27 minutes ago, dave_min said:

Gus is decent. Fuck knows why he doesn’t get a game.

I think he's OK. I felt Pollock and Scales were better than him last year and helped him a lot.

This year he was injured at the start of the season and when he did get his chance (St Mirren game I think), he was hopeless and rightly dropped. He maybe wasn't fully fit at that point tbf.

He probably should've had another chance since then as you can definitely make a case for dropping all rhe defenders. Jensen may be the one who survives due to being the only lefty.

[Andy_123]

1 hour ago, dave_min said:

Gus is decent. Fuck knows why he doesn’t get a game.

Strolled the game v Killie. No idea why he was subbed

[CCB III]

17 hours ago, RUL said:

All he did was foul our defenders all night.

Crazy how little the boy Vassell actually looks at the football for a striker. 
 

More interested in getting in tussles than trapping and holding the ball up. 
 

Thought the defence was fine on Wednesday. Conceded next to nothing from open play until the goal. 

[englishred]

7 hours ago, Turra red said:

On Wednesday night especially I thought the fault wasn't with our defence. They dealt with the majority of attacks well however when your midfield is non existent you will always struggle to thwart every attack. 

I think the defence could be solid and in attack we are well equipped, it's the engine room that's wrong and robson wont change it.

We are desperate for some quality in midfield. Polvara is fine for example but he is developing, we need people in their prime. Even shinnie struggles at times now