Should He Stay Or Should He Go Now?

[Ke1t]

There's always an element of 'Get him tae fuck' versus 'He just needs more time' when it comes to our yearly Sacking O The Manager.

After the latest debacle is it time to dust off the 'We'd Like To Thank The Manager For His Services' press release? 

Or are we too early in the season for all that nonsense? 

 

[CraigHill]

We can keep firing managers if we keep employing ones that are inexperienced / shite / combination of both.

Expensive, but necessary habit.

Get him tae fuck!

[Bournemouth Gee]

Fuck off Robson. Glassball was better than this

[Kincardine_Mearns_Red]

Knowing Cormack he will drag this out for as long as possible.

[The Gee Man]

Unfortunately he has to go now

[Johnnyred1]

Sack the next manager while we're at it.

[donswin1983]

10 minutes ago, Ke1t said:

There's always an element of 'Get him tae fuck' versus 'He just needs more time' when it comes to our yearly Sacking O The Manager.

After the latest debacle is it time to dust off the 'We'd Like To Thank The Manager For His Services' press release? 

Or are we too early in the season for all that nonsense? 

 

You and I debated the possibility of relegation a while back! I was very much of the view that it wouldn’t happen, predicated on BR being removed from duty sooner rather than later. Other clubs and a dead club have made the managerial change! If we don’t, imminently, I feel that relegation is a very real possibility mate. 
so, in short, with c25% of the league season gone, it’s not too early at all. In my opinion. Every passing league game is likely to cost us based on current league performance! 

[Dynamo]

He'll get a little longer but there's an inevitability about it. 

[Joe pike]

3 minutes ago, Dynamo said:

He'll get a little longer but there's an inevitability about it. 

No way he’s getting sacked before the Hibs game.

[WesthillWanderersFC]

He should be gone already.

To be replaced by a manager with a CV worthy of the job, and with some experience. 
Not a bang average development manager. 

He’s massively out of his depth. 

Paraphrasing… GTF 

[Rubin]

we are also reducing the sell on value of Miovski

a decent, or even just capable manager,  might earn us a couple million more in that direction

[Joe pike]

Just now, Rubin said:

we are also reducing the sell on value of Miovski

a decent, or even just capable manager,  might earn us a couple million more in that direction

And Duk

 

[Frank Grimes]

8 minutes ago, Dynamo said:

He'll get a little longer but there's an inevitability about it. 

This, probably 

Likely to the next international break 

Hopefully it doesn’t cost us a trophy which we do have a realistic shot at due to Sevco, Hearts & Hibs also being shite 

[donswin1983]

4 minutes ago, Joe pike said:

And Duk

 

He’s doing a decent job of that himself, min! 
very odd what happening there 

[milne_afc]

5 minutes ago, Joe pike said:

No way he’s getting sacked before the Hibs game.

He’ll get the dead rubber league fixtures against the Glasgow 2

[G man]

6 minutes ago, Joe pike said:

And Duk

 

Duk is doing that on the back of his dreadful performances this season.

[Willo flood]

I genuinely don’t see the point of giving him the Hibs game, although it will most certainly happen.

Why do we always wait until we are out of every competition before punting the manager? If Cormack genuinely can’t see through Robson after today then he should be on the next bus to Cornhill

[strachanmcgheegoal]

Said it six weeks ago.  Either he has to get ruthless with the under performers or the Club will get ruthless with him.

[Hoofball]

He wants sacked, if he didn’t he’d change system and style of play especially against the likes of St Johnstone and Kilmarnock. Get him to fuck and get someone with experience in that can setup a team to win

[WesthillWanderersFC]

1 minute ago, Willo flood said:

I genuinely don’t see the point of giving him the Hibs game, although it will most certainly happen.

Why do we always wait until we are out of every competition before punting the manager? If Cormack genuinely can’t see through Robson after today then he should be on the next bus to Cornhill

How long do we have to wait?

Let’s be honest, the way we’re playing, we’re unlikely to win any of the next 4.

Motherwell (a) Same as today   
Hibs semi - oot. 
PAOK (a) - any score you like. 
Celtic (a) - any score you like.

Every chance we’ll be 11th in league & out the League Cup & Europe.

 

[JamieMT]

Sadly Barry Robson's time is up. He was the wrong appointment and prolonging his tenure will benefit no one.

That said, i don't see him getting the sack until well into the new year. ☹️

[Kincardine_Mearns_Red]

If we had proper standards at the club like we used to say 30 odd years ago he would be gone. Sadly we dont and he is still here. The weakness starts at the top.

[NorfolkDandy]

3 minutes ago, Hoofball said:

He wants sacked, if he didn’t he’d change system and style of play especially against the likes of St Johnstone and Kilmarnock. Get him to fuck and get someone with experience in that can setup a team to win

I 'suggested' similar, tongue in cheek, in the match thread

Now, of course, I'm sure that's the case

However, it's eye bleeding, and infuriating, as we have the players to perform far better than they're set up

[zeroisgod76]

Don’t let the door hit him on the way out.

Having said that Cormack isn’t going to sack him. He didn’t sack Goodwin after the 5-0 at Tynecastle and Darvel.  He’ll watch as we lose out next 6 games then come out of hiding to say he backs him before eventually firing him a few weeks later when we’re bottom of the league, out of Europe and out of the league cup.

[The Gee Man]

1 minute ago, zeroisgod76 said:

Don’t let the door hit him on the way out.

Having said that Cormack isn’t going to sack him. He didn’t sack Goodwin after the 5-0 at Tynecastle and Darvel.  He’ll watch as we lose out next 6 games then come out of hiding to say he backs him before eventually firing him a few weeks later when we’re bottom of the league, out of Europe and out of the league cup.

Cormack should have learned we likely wouldn’t have lost to Darvel if he acted quicker 

[Willo flood]

21 minutes ago, WesthillWanderersFC said:

How long do we have to wait?

Let’s be honest, the way we’re playing, we’re unlikely to win any of the next 4.

Motherwell (a) Same as today   
Hibs semi - oot. 
PAOK (a) - any score you like. 
Celtic (a) - any score you like.

Every chance we’ll be 11th in league & out the League Cup & Europe.

 

I can’t see him surviving the next week if we fail to win both games but who knows what’s going through the heads of the FMB right now

They might feel it’s probably more beneficial letting Robson have the next 2 then sacking him now and having Stuart Duff and Hayes on the sideline for the Semi, where we may as well not turn up.

The logical thing for the board to do in that case is to start looking for replacements now, if they haven’t already so we are not starting from scratch after a loss to Hibs, again. But I wouldn’t hold my breath.

[Jazzer08]

He wasn't the right appointment to begin with. I gave him my backing when he got the full time gig, but he's been shown up to be completely inept.

Countless others have said it - no rookie should be given the Aberdeen job on a permanent basis. This isn't a job for someone taking their first steps in first team management. We need someone experienced and with a good track record. 

Get him oot.

Challinor sounds like a good shout. His managerial stats look great at all four clubs he's managed, although much smaller clubs than ours. Can he take the step up? 

[WesthillWanderersFC]

2 minutes ago, Willo flood said:

I can’t see him surviving the next week if we fail to win both games but who knows what’s going through the heads of the FMB right now

They might feel it’s probably more beneficial letting Robson have the next 2 then sacking him now and having Stuart Duff and Hayes on the sideline for the Semi, where we may as well not turn up.

The logical thing for the board to do in that case is to start looking for replacements now, if they haven’t already so we are not starting from scratch after a loss to Hibs, again. But I wouldn’t hold my breath.

And another fundamental, but important issue is that I don’t trust the likes of Gunn/Garner/Milne to appoint a decent manager.

[donswin1983]

1 minute ago, WesthillWanderersFC said:

And another fundamental, but important issue is that I don’t trust the likes of Gunn/Garner/Milne to appoint a decent manager.

Is a good point….that gives me the fear!

[DelMonte]

5 minutes ago, WesthillWanderersFC said:

And another fundamental, but important issue is that I don’t trust the likes of Gunn/Garner/Milne to appoint a decent manager.

Or Cormack himself. He is the main issue at the club, clearly.