Jump to content

Scottish Communities Cup 3rd Round Draw


Recommended Posts

then youd be, again, UTTERLY wrong

 

 

I refer you to the last accusation of me being utterly wrong.

Brown saves a proper hiding.

 

Had it not been for former Celtic and Hibernian goalkeeper Mark Brown, making his debut after signing a short-term contract, it could have been a more heavy defeat for the Dingwall outfit.

 

 

You don't think changing four people in a team isn't making wholesale changes?

 

How many changes do you think it takes to make a wholesale change?

Link to comment

by definition, wholesale would need to be the majority of the team changed

 

as for you not being wrong about brown because he only let in 4 on his debut...hows that proving hes better than langfield or "jase"?

 

 

Where did I say I'm right about Mark Brown because he only let in 4 goals last night? :dontknow:

 

The definition of wholesale is not majority but large, 4 out of 11 players being changed...

 

Thank you.

Link to comment

On what basis did you make a definitive statement that Brown M was better than Brown J or Langfield?

 

Bearing in mind he was in goals when we put 4 past Celtic at Pittodrie.

 

 

On my opinion of having seen all three goalkeepers in action.

 

Mark Brown is the better goalkeeper of those three keepers.

 

What is the relevance of letting in 4 goals while he played for Celtic?

 

Peter Schmeichel let in 5 for Manchester United.

 

He must be worse than Brown going by your logic.

Link to comment

In the Celtic game I mentioned he had no command of his area, no presence and no shot stopping ability.

 

What aspects if his game do you know for sure are better than Brown or Langfield?

 

 

 

Have you other evidence of Mark Brown having no command of his area, no presence and no shot stopping ability or are you basing your judgement on 1 game?

 

 

Regarding the aspects of his game, for me he looks like a keeper who has more confidence and command in his penalty box area than our keepers.

 

Of course that's my opinion and not absolute fact so can only be taken in that context.

 

It would be impossible to prove absolute that Mark Brown is a better goalkeeper than our pair of clowns in all aspects but from what I know and have seen of all three keepers I have made my decision that Mark Brown is the better goalkeeper.

 

You may disagree with that and you're welcome to do so.

 

It doesn't affect my opinion if you choose to do so.

Link to comment

On what basis did you make a definitive statement that Brown M was better than Brown J or Langfield?

 

Bearing in mind he was in goals when we put 4 past Celtic at Pittodrie.

 

He hardly got a sniff at Celtic and being thrown in for odd games doesn't help a keeper. Like Howard and Langfield under McGhee. He was an outstanding keeper back in his Inverness days. Nae sure what he's like now as I've hardly seen him play.

Link to comment

I think this is how it looks now...

 

Seeded Teams:

Celtic

Motherwell

Dundee Utd

Hearts

St. Johnstone

Aberdeen

St. Mirren

Inverness CT

 

Unseeded Teams:

Dunfermline

Sevco / Falkirk

Hamilton

Livingston

Raith Rovers

Queen of the South

Stenhousemuir

Queens Park

FFs.

A few lower league AFC tragedies from the past in that little lot!

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...