Liam Scales

[jamiesd]

22 minutes ago, NEM said:

Stewart and the hun cunt at centre half give me the fear

Aye its a disaster waiting to happen.

[Ten Caat]

I think Stewart + Scales is > Stewart + Mccrorie but not by a massive amount.

I'm resigned to taking nothing from the game anyway so if they manage to surprise me (and likely everyone) by keeping Timothy out it'll be an unexpected bonus

[thurso]

3 at the back suits all 3. 2 at the back suite no one 

[Andy_123]

2 hours ago, jamiesd said:

Anyone think he will be a miss on Saturday?  Im not so sure he will be much of a miss to be honest.

Our defence is pish with him, and it’ll be pish without him

[Don_Corleone]

I think Scales has been pretty good - I think he might be better alongside someone who isn't Stewart.

[Millertime]

5 hours ago, jamiesd said:

Anyone think he will be a miss on Saturday?  Im not so sure he will be much of a miss to be honest.

Then you're, with respect, off your nut

[strachanmcgheegoal]

Yay.  Stand in centre half against the nip and no right back against the George Michael lookie likey.  Classic us.  Expecting classic Timothy.

[King Street Loon]

21 hours ago, jamiesd said:

Anyone think he will be a miss on Saturday?  Im not so sure he will be much of a miss to be honest.

Of course he will be.

Whether you like it or not he is our best centre half.

[Broken_Glass]

On 12/15/2022 at 11:09 AM, King Street Loon said:

Of course he will be.

Whether you like it or not he is our best centre half.

I personally thought that Mackenzie was brilliant at left centre back today. Quicker and stronger than Scales and won't cost us a penny.

 

Would happily give him an extended run in that position.

[The Gee Man]

Still a waiting game to see if Scales stays for rest of season. I assume he’s only going back if someone bids for him. But you would think you would know by now and pretty poor planning by the club

[NEM]

4 minutes ago, The Gee Man said:

Still a waiting game to see if Scales stays for rest of season. I assume he’s only going back if someone bids for him. But you would think you would know by now and pretty poor planning by the club

Rather play McKenzie left centre half than develop a tim.  Send the cunt back

[Broken_Glass]

4 minutes ago, The Gee Man said:

Still a waiting game to see if Scales stays for rest of season. I assume he’s only going back if someone bids for him. But you would think you would know by now and pretty poor planning by the club

Aye really poor. Imagine not telling the fans if we have an alternative lined up before the transfer window is even open, or we are happy to stick with MacKenzie after his brilliant display on Saturday.

Scales has regressed, therefore I have no issues if he stays or goes. When you speak to Celtic fans they say his problem was consistency - I would agree.

 

[aberdeen1970]

1 minute ago, Broken_Glass said:

Aye really poor. Imagine not telling the fans if we have an alternative lined up before the transfer window is even open, or we are happy to stick with MacKenzie after his brilliant display on Saturday.

Scales has regressed, therefore I have no issues if he stays or goes. When you speak to Celtic fans they say his problem was consistency - I would agree.

 

I thought he'd already been confirmed on loan for the season when he initially arrived? 

I get that folk are pissed off about the tactics on Saturday but this is a non story. 

[CCB III]

5 minutes ago, Broken_Glass said:

Aye really poor. Imagine not telling the fans if we have an alternative lined up before the transfer window is even open, or we are happy to stick with MacKenzie after his brilliant display on Saturday.

Scales has regressed, therefore I have no issues if he stays or goes. When you speak to Celtic fans they say his problem was consistency - I would agree.

 

And I'm meant to be brain dead 😂

[Broken_Glass]

3 minutes ago, aberdeen1970 said:

I thought he'd already been confirmed on loan for the season when he initially arrived? 

I get that folk are pissed off about the tactics on Saturday but this is a non story. 

People love sensationalism.

[Guest findlay_1903]

Just now, Broken_Glass said:

People love sensationalism.

Football loves it. 

[The Gee Man]

15 minutes ago, Broken_Glass said:

Aye really poor. Imagine not telling the fans if we have an alternative lined up before the transfer window is even open, or we are happy to stick with MacKenzie after his brilliant display on Saturday.

Scales has regressed, therefore I have no issues if he stays or goes. When you speak to Celtic fans they say his problem was consistency - I would agree.

 

Wasn’t about us announcing other signings etc, just find it weird that potentially the guy who has played in the back all season could be away in a few weeks and we don’t know. Would have thought we would have something in place with scales loan to say let us know by early December or he stays sort of thing. 

[aberdeen1970]

6 minutes ago, The Gee Man said:

Wasn’t about us announcing other signings etc, just find it weird that potentially the guy who has played in the back all season could be away in a few weeks and we don’t know. Would have thought we would have something in place with scales loan to say let us know by early December or he stays sort of thing. 

He's on loan for the season min. 

[The Gee Man]

6 minutes ago, aberdeen1970 said:

He's on loan for the season min. 

Recall option 

[aberdeen1970]

1 minute ago, The Gee Man said:

Recall option 

Would that not be the case for Clarkson and Coulson as well? 

Why not the same fuss about them?  We'd be equally down to bare bones in their positions too if they left. 

You're making a big fuss about nothing. Even if he does go back we've got a whole month to find a replacement. 

 

[The Gee Man]

Just now, aberdeen1970 said:

Would that not be the case for Clarkson and Coulson as well? 

Why not the same fuss about them?  We'd be equally down to bare bones in their positions too if they left. 

You're making a big fuss about nothing. Even if he does go back we've got a whole month to find a replacement. 

 

My actual point is that surely this should be agreed by early December not start of January. If you don’t agree that’s fine 

[aberdeen1970]

1 minute ago, The Gee Man said:

My actual point is that surely this should be agreed by early December not start of January. If you don’t agree that’s fine 

How do you know its not already been agreed? 

[The Gee Man]

1 minute ago, aberdeen1970 said:

How do you know its not already been agreed? 

Liam Scales Aberdeen loan latest as Jim Goodwin reveals Celtic talks waiting game over recall option

[aberdeen1970]

1 minute ago, The Gee Man said:

Liam Scales Aberdeen loan latest as Jim Goodwin reveals Celtic talks waiting game over recall option

Can't see them enacting the clause, they've signed a few defenders since he came here. He's well down their pecking order. 

And if they sell him this window there's not much we can do about it, unless we're buying him ourselves. 

He's decent but replaceable.

 

 

[Ten Caat]

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/jim-goodwin-sweating-celtic-decision-28772424

The headline seems to be sensationalising something that the story in reality makes clear that Goodwin expects not to happen.

[Joe pike]

1 hour ago, Ten Caat said:

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/jim-goodwin-sweating-celtic-decision-28772424

The headline seems to be sensationalising something that the story in reality makes clear that Goodwin expects not to happen.

2 defenders and a midfielder incoming January.

😉😉😉

[Dave Bus]

What’s the mid season verdict on this guy? Is he good enough? Not even our player so is doing a deal worth looking into?

[Ten Caat]

I think he's bang average. There would be plenty of equally bang average central defender available to sign on pre-contracts.

Obviously Goodwin rates him though. If his price is £500k as has been speculated, he's not worth it. I'd say he's a £250k player at best

[Millertime]

7 minutes ago, Ten Caat said:

I think he's bang average. There would be plenty of equally bang average central defender available to sign on pre-contracts.

Obviously Goodwin rates him though. If his price is £500k as has been speculated, he's not worth it. I'd say he's a £250k player at best

Away you go

He is really good, was dragged down by the general state of us recently

Well worth 500k

[King Street Loon]

He's worth a contract. 

A good player who has been struggling with confidence of late like the rest of them.